Решение по адм. дело №456/2024 на Административен съд - Сливен

юя<style type="text/css">.body-text { font-size:12pt !important; } </style> ( <5@">! 1790 !;825=, 04.10.2024 3. " 4<8=8AB@0B82=8OB AJ4 - !;825= - IV AJAB02, 2 AJ451=> 70A540=85 =0 ?J@28 >:B><2@8 425 E8;O48 42045A5B 8 G5B2J@B0 3>48=0 2 AJAB02: <table border="0" class="body-text" dir="ltr" style="width: 100%; margin: 40px 0px 40px;"> <tbody> <tr> <td style="text-align: right;">!J48O: </td> <td style="text-align: left; vertical-align: top; width:300px;"> </td> </tr> <tr> <td style="text-align: right; vertical-align: top;"> </td> <td style="text-align: left; vertical-align: top; width:300px;"> </td> </tr> </tbody> </table> @8 A5:@5B0@ :C@>@0"> 8 A CG0AB85B> =0 ?@>:C@>@0 ! B AJ48O"> :0B> @073;540 4>:;0420=>B> >B AJ48O 284 45;> =><5@"> 04<8=8AB@0B82=> 45;> ! 20247220700456 / 2024 3., 70 40 A5 ?@>87=5A5 275 ?@54284 A;54=>B>:  <div class="rtf" dir="ltr" style="margin-bottom:.2pt;text-indent:35.45pt;font-size:12pt;font-family:MS Sans Serif; text-align: justify;"> @>872>4AB2>B> 5 ?> @540 =0 G;. 84 0;. 3, 2J2 2@. A G;. 75 0;. 1 B. 2 8 B. 4 >B 0:>= 70 C1568I5B> 8 1560=F8B5 (#). 1@07C20=> 5 ?> 60;10 =0 <a name="_Hlk159166760">. . $., A ' ..............., [4J@6020], A 04@5A & =0 ?@8 ! – [=0A5;5=> <OAB>] A@5IC 5H5=85 ! 8766/16.08.2024 3. =0 @54A540B5;O =0 J@602=0B0 035=F8O 70 1560=F8B5 ?@8 8=8AB5@A:8 AJ25B, A :>5B> =0 60;1>?>40B5;O 5 >B:070=> ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB.</a> 60;10B0 A5 A>G8, G5 @5H5=85B> 5 =570:>=>AJ>1@07=>, ?>@048 4>?CA=0B8 ?@8 ?>AB0=>2O20=5B> <C AJI5AB25=8 =0@CH5=8O =0 04<8=8AB@0B82=> ?@>872>4AB25=8B5 ?@028;0 8 ?@>B82>@5G85 A ?@8;>68<8O <0B5@80;5= 70:>=. 4<8=8AB@0B82=8OB >@30= =5?@028;=> 8 2 ?@>B82>@5G85 A <0B5@80;=8O 70:>= ?@85;, G5 [4J@6020] 5 B@5B0 A83C@=0 4J@6020 70 >A?>@20I8O. !G8B0, G5 AJI0B0 =5 >B3>20@O =0 >?@545;5=85B> 2 § 1, B. 9 1. &bdquo;1“, 1. "3" 8 1. &bdquo;4“ >B =0 # 70 "B@5B0 A83C@=0 4J@6020", BJ9 :0B> D0:B8G5A:8 B>9 =5 <>65; 40 C?@06=O20 ?@020B0 A8 B0<, ?>@048 ?>;8B8:0B0 =0 B078 4J@6020 :J< A. 1.. >7>2020 A5 =0 AB0B8O >B <548OB0 &bdquo;>9G5 25;5“, 8=D>@<0F8OB0 2 :>OB> AJ2?040;0 A ?@85B ?@57 2021 3. 53;0<5=B =0 >B=>A=> :>=D;8:B0 2 [4J@6020], A?>@54 :>8B> 87B>G=8F8 A5 ?@87>2020;0 [4J@6020] 40 ?@5CAB0=>28 45?>@B8@0=5B> =0 A. >1@0B=> 2 [4J@6020] ?@>B82 2>;OB0 8<. "578 40==8 A>G5;8, G5 A?@O<> A. 1. 2 [4J@6020] 8 2 G0AB=>AB A?@O<> =53> =5 AJI5AB2C20 70I8B0 >B ?@8=C48B5;=> 2@JI0=5 =0 B5@8B>@8OB0 =0 [4J@6020]. @57C<?F8OB0 70 A83C@=>AB =0 4045=0 4J@6020 2 A?8AJF8B5 =0 !, =0 :>8B> A5 ?>7>2020; >B25B=8OB >@30= 18;0 >1>@8<0 ?> A8;0B0 =0 G;. 99 >B #, 0:> BJ@A5I8OB 70:@8;0 <>65 40 ?@54AB028 4>:070B5;AB20 8;8 4>2>48, G5 70 =53> B078 AB@0=0 =5 5 A83C@=0 ?>@048 B2J@4O=8B5 >1AB>OB5;AB20. !G8B0, G5 ?@8 0=0;870 =0 A8BC0F8OB0 2 [4J@6020] 04<8=8AB@0B82=8OB >@30= 5 ?>4E>48; D>@<0;=>, 4>:>;:>B> 2 ?@0:B8:0B0 A8 !' <=>3>:@0B=> >1@JI0; 2=8<0=85 2J@EC ?@542848<8B5 ?>A;548F8 >B ?@8=C48B5;=> 8725640=5 =0 ;8F5B> 2 ?@54;>65=0B0 4J@6020 =0 2@JI0=5. >A?>@5=8O 0:B ;8?A20;8 87;>65=8 <>B828, G5 [4J@6020] 18 3> ?@85;0 >1@0B=> 8 18 <C ?@54>AB028;0 <564C=0@>4=0 70:@8;0. >;8 AJ40 40 >B<5=8 >A?>@5=>B> @5H5=85 AJA 70:>==8B5 ?>A;548F8 >B B>20. >B:@8B> AJ451=> 70A540=85 >A?>@20I8OB, @54>2=> 8 A2>52@5<5==> ?@87>20= A5 O2O20 ;8G=> 8 A =04;56=> C?J;=><>I5= 042. . !. >B – [>1;0AB], :>OB> ?>44J@60 60;10B0 8 <>;8 AJ40 40 O C2068. 0O2O20 A5 <0B5@80;=0 8 ?@>F5AC0;=0 =570:>=>AJ>1@07=>AB =0 >A?>@5=>B> 04<8=8AB@0B82=> @5H5=85. @8 =53>2>B> ?>AB0=>2O20=5 =5 18;8 0=0;878@0=8 2A8G:8 D0:B8 8 >1AB>OB5;AB20, G@57 :>8B> 40 A5 CAB0=>28 >15:B82=0B0 8AB8=0 8 A5 ?@5F5=8 ?@028;=> =5>1E>48<>ABB0 >B 70:@8;0 =0 . $.. @5H5=85B> =8:J45 =5 18;> A?><5=0B> G5 B>9 5 ?@5182020; 2 [4J@6020] 8 <5A5F0, 0 =5 8 3>48=8, 0 8=B5@2NB> A5 ?@>25;> G@57 2845>@073>2>@ 8 2@J7:0B0 18;0 <=>3> ;>H0, A ?@5:JA20=8O 8 =54>@07C<5=8O <564C ?@525640I8O 8 8=B5@2N8@0=>B> ;8F5. 0:0@ ?> 4>:C<5=B8 40 A5 AG8B0;0 [4J@6020] 70 B@5B0 A83C@=0 AB@0=0, B> B>20 =0 ?@0:B8:0 =5 18;> B0:0. . 18;8 C., 1. 8 ?@8=C48B5;=> 2@JI0=8 2 AB@0=0B0 A8 =0 ?@>87E>4 >B B. 2.. 8:J45 2 @5H5=85B> =5 18;> C?><5=0B> >I5, G5 =53>28B5 A. 8 4. A0 ?@8=C48B5;=> 2J@=0B8 2 [4J@6020] 8 B>9 =O<0 8=D>@<0F8O 70 BOE, 0 A0 18;8 7054=> 2 [4J@6020]. :> A530 1J45; 2J@=0B 2 [4J@6020], IO; 40 1J45 ?@8=C48B5;=> 2J@=0B 2 [4J@6020], :J45B> AJI5AB2C20;0 2J7<>6=>AB 40 1J45 C.. =>3> =>@<0B82=8 0:B>25 70I8B020;8 G>25H:8B5 ?@020 8 2@JI09:8 3> 2 [4J@6020], =5 A0<> I5 1J40B =0@CH5=8 B5E=8B5 =>@<8, => 8 IO;> 40 5 =0;8F5 AJ3;0A85 40 1J45 C. 548= G. 6.. >;8 A5 AJ40 40 ?>AB0=>28 >B<O=0 =0 @5H5=85B> 8 2@JI0=5 =0 ?@5?8A:0B0 70 =>2> ?@>87=0AO=5, A ?@>25640=5 =0 =>2> 8=B5@2N, ?>@048 B>20, G5 8=B5@2NB> A5 5 ?@>25;> G@57 2845>@073>2>@ 8 AJ>B25B=> A5 5 ?>;CG8;> @07<8=020=5 2 8=D>@<0F8OB0. >B:@8B> AJ451=> 70A540=85 >B25B=8:JB – @54A540B5; =0 J@602=0 035=F8O 70 1560=F8B5 ?@8 8=8AB5@A:8 AJ25B, G@57 ?@>F5AC0;5= ?@54AB028B5; N@: . ". >A?>@20 60;10B0 8 <>;8 AJ40 40 O >BE2J@;8. >44J@60, G5 ". A5 O2O20 B@5B0 A83C@=0 AB@0=0. ?8A<5=8 15;56:8 @072820 ?>4@>1=8 AJ>1@065=8O 2 ?>4:@5?0 =0 B2J@45=8OB0 A8 70 <0B5@80;=0 8 ?@>F5AC0;=0 70:>=>AJ>1@07=>AB =0 0B0:C20=>B> 04<8=8AB@0B82=> @5H5=85. >B:@8B> AJ451=> 70A540=85 ?@54AB028B5;OB =0 :@J6=0 ?@>:C@0BC@0 – !;825= 70ABJ?20 AB0=>28I5 70 =5>A=>20B5;=>AB =0 60;10B0. 0O2O20, G5 4>:070B5;AB20B0 ?> ?@8;>65=0B0 04<8=8AB@0B82=0 ?@5?8A:0 4020B >A=>20=85 40 A5 ?@85<5, G5 @5H5=85B> 5 275B> 2J7 >A=>20 =0 87OA=5=8 D0:B8 8 >1AB>OB5;AB20 8 ?@8 =0;8G85 =0 4>AB0BJG=8 ?8A<5=8 8 4@C38 87B>G=8F8, :>8B> 40 >1>A=>2020B D>@<8@0=8B5 2 0:B0 872>48. 0O2O20 <>B828@0=>AB, ?>A;54>20B5;=>AB 8 ;>38:0 ?@8 0=0;870 =0 157A?>@=8 4>:C<5=B8, 4>:0720I8 =09 – 7=0G8<8O D0:B 2 =0AB>OI>B> ?@>872>4AB2> – 5 ;8, 8;8 =5 5 ". 2 =0AB>OI8O <><5=B B@5B0 A83C@=0 AB@0=0. !G8B0, G5 87;>65=8B5 >B >A?>@20I0B0 AB@0=0 B2J@45=8O A0 >AB0=0;8 =54>:070=8 8 =5?>4:@5?5=8 >B 4>:070B5;AB25=0B0 AJ2:C?=>AB ?> 45;>B>. >;8 AJ40 40 ?@85<5 60;10B0 70 =5>A=>20B5;=0. !J4JB, :0B> >1AJ48 4>2>48B5 =0 AB@0=8B5 2 ?@>872>4AB2>B> 8 AJ1@0=8B5 ?> 45;>B> 4>:070B5;AB20, ?@85<0 70 CAB0=>25=> A;54=>B> >B D0:B8G5A:0 AB@0=0: !JA 0?>254 @53. ! 6865-467/27.05.2024 3. =0 0G0;=8: 3@0=8G=> ?>;8F59A:> C?@02;5=85 - . ?> >B=>H5=85 =0 . $., [4J@6020] 18;0 ?@8;>65=0 ?@8=C48B5;=0 04<8=8AB@0B82=0 <O@:0, >15:B828@0=0 :0B> &bdquo;@JI0=5 4> AB@0=0 =0 ?@>87E>4“. B AJ4J@60=85B> =0 0:B0, AJAB02;O20I> D0:B8G5A:> >A=>20=85 70 =53>2>B> ?>AB0=>2O20=5 A5 CAB0=>2O20, G5 =0 AJI0B0 40B0 =0 3;025= ?JB I-7, @09>= ". A;C68B5;8 =0 &bdquo;@0=8G=0 ?>;8F8O“ A0 A?@5;8 8 872J@H8;8 ?@>25@:0 =0 C. B>20@5= 02B><>18;, C?@02;O20= >B C. 3., :0B> 2 ?>;C@5<0@:5B> A0 CAB0=>25=8 5 ;8F0 157 4>:C<5=B8 70 A0<>;8G=>AB, :>8B> =5 <>30B 40 CAB0=>2OB 2;870=5B> A8 2 AB@0=0B0 ?> 70:>=>CAB0=>25=8O @54. > A8;0B0 =0 =0AB0=8B5;=> @5H5=85 ! 124/11.06.2024 3. $. 18; =0AB0=5= 2 & – [=0A5;5=> <OAB>] ?@8 . ! <>;10 4> J@602=0 035=F8O 70 1560=F8B5 2E. ! #3825/11.06.2024 3. =0AB>OI8OB 60;1>?>40B5;O . $. ?>8A:0; 70:@8;0 >B 2;0AB8B5 2 J;30@8O. 0 AJI0B0 40B0 GC645=5FJB 2 ?@8AJAB285 =0 ?@52>40G 18; 70?>7=0B A @540 70 ?>4020=5 =0 <>;10 70 <564C=0@>4=0 70:@8;0 8 ?@>F54C@0B0, :>OB> I5 A5 A;5420, :0:B> 8 A ?@020B0 8 704J;65=8OB0 =0 GC645=F8B5, ?>40;8 <>;10 70 70:@8;0 2 J;30@8O, :><?5B5=B=8O >@30= ?> ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 C1568I5, AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB, ?@5182020=5 2 J;30@8O, 704J;65=8O =0 GC645=F8B5, =0AB0=5=8 2 F5=B@>25 =0 8 8=D>@<0F8O 70 >1@01>B20=5 =0 ;8G=8 40==8 =0 GC645=F8, BJ@A5I8 <564C=0@>4=0 70:@8;0, 284=> >B #:070=8O # 3825/11.06.2024 3., 254=> A 4>?J;=5=85 :J< BOE, =AB@C:F8O ! #3825/11.06.2024 3. 8 =D>@<0F8O ! #3825/11.06.2024 3. !0<>;8G=>ABB0 =0 GC645=5F0 18;0 CAB0=>25=0 A 45:;0@0F8O ?> G;. 30 0;. 1 B. 3 >B #, 702545=0 A @53. ! #3825/11.06.2024 3., 284=> >B :>OB> BJ@A5I>B> 70:@8;0 ;8F5 A5 8=48284C0;878@0;> A 8. . (A. 8.) . (1. 8.) $. (D. 8.), [4J@6020], @>45= =0 [40B0]. 2 [4J@6020], [=0A5;5=> <OAB>], A. ?. - [A5<59=> ?>;>65=85]. 'C645=5FJB 5 18; @538AB@8@0= G@57 ?>?J;20=5 =0 @538AB@0F8>=5= ;8AB A @53. !#3825/11.06.2024 3. :0B> . . $., 3. - [4J@6020], 5. ?. - :., @. – <., A., ?. 0., >. – =., A. ?. – [A5<59=> ?>;>65=85], 4. – . $. =0 6 3. 8 . $. =0 4 3., A <. 2 "., <. . . 8 1. . $. A <. 2 "., 1. 8 A. 2 ". 8 1. . $. =0 29 3. 2 [4J@6020] (;. 60). ! >:0=0 @53. ! #3825/11.06.2024 3. $. 18; ?@8:0=5= 40 A5 O28 =0 8=B5@2N 2 & – [=0A5;5=> <OAB>] =0 19.06.2024 3. (;. 58). ! 8A<> @53. ! #3825/13.06.2024 3. 8@5:B>@ =0 & – [=0A5;5=> <OAB>] ?@8 ?>8A:0; >B !?5F80;878@0=0 48@5:F8O "" - ! ?8A<5=> AB0=>28I5 ?> ?>ABJ?8;0B0 >B . . $. <>;10 70 70:@8;0 (;. 53). ! >B3>2>@ @53. ! -10458/15.07.2024 3. 8@5:B>@ =0 ! &bdquo;“ – ! >B 8<5B> =0 48@5:F8OB0 =5 2J7@078; :J< <><5=B0 =0 ;8F5B> 40 A5 ?@54>AB028 70:@8;0, 2 A;CG09, G5 >B3>20@O =0 878A:20=8OB0 =0 # (;. 47). 0 19.06.2024 3. A <>;8B5;O . . $. 18;> ?@>2545=> 8=B5@2N, >15:B828@0=> 2 @>B>:>; @53. ! #3825, ?@>2545=> 2 ?@8AJAB285B> 8 A CG0AB85B> =0 ?@52>40G >B :. 5.. (;. 48). 'C645=5FJB 70O28;, G5 =5 AJI5AB2C20B ?@5G:8 >B 7. 8;8 ?. E0@0:B5@ 70 ?@>25640=5 =0 8=B5@2NB>; ?>B2J@48; :070=>B> ?@8 ?>?J;20=5 =0 @538AB@0F8>==8O ;8AB, 8<0; 1. 2 [4J@6020] – . =0 29 3>48=8, AJA 70:@8;0, EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB; ?@8 =0?CA:0=5 =0 4J@6020B0 ?> ?@>87E>4 =5 =>A5; 4>:C<5=B 70 A0<>;8G=>AB, A5<59=0B0 <C :=86:0 18;0 2 [4J@6020], 0 ;8G=0B0 <C :0@B0 18;0 >B:@04=0B0; =0?CA=0; =5;530;=> 70 [4J@6020] ?@57 2015 3., :0B> B0< ?@5182020; 8 3>48=8 2 [=0A5;5=> <OAB>], ?@548 >:>;> <5A5F A B>20@5= 02B><>18; CA?O; 40 ?@5<8=5 ?@57 1.-B. 3@0=8F0; >?8B0; 40 275<5 4>:C<5=B8 >B B. 2., => =5 CA?O; 8 682O; =.; >?8B0; 40 ?@5<8=5 3@0=8F0B0 A [4J@6020] ?@57 2019 3., ?>@048 :>5B> <C >B:0720;8 <=>3>:@0B=> 874020=5 =0 4>:C<5=B8; @. 2 <OAB> 70 3. =0 4.; 2 ". =5 5 8<0; ?@>1;5<8, =0?CA=0;, ?>@048 ;8?A0B0 =0 4>:C<5=B8 8 A., G5 I5 1J45 4. 2 [4J@6020]; 4. <C A5 =0<8@0;8 2 [4J@6020] 8 70 BOE A5 3@865;8 =53>28B5 <. 8 1.; 4. <C 18;8 @. 2 ". 2 [=0A5;5=> <OAB>]; <. =0 4. <C 8 AJ>B25B=> – B5 8<0;8 874045=8 >B ". 4>:C<5=B8 70 A0<>;8G=>AB; 2 [4J@6020] 18; 0. 70 15 4=8 ?>@048 =. =0 :. 157 >. ?@57 2013 3.; =5 18; >. 2 4J@6020B0 ?> ?@>87E>4, =O<0; ?@>1;5<8 70@048 5. A8 ?.; 18; <. 8 =O<0; ?@>1;5<8 70@048 @. A8, =5 C. 2 @. >., >., A.; A. <C ?. 18; [A5<59=> ?>;>65=85] >B 2022 3.; =0 @. <C, :>8B> 68255;8 2 ". 8 8<0;8 7. ?. ?><030; ?>-<. <C 1., B5 AJI> =O<0;8 &bdquo;:.“, 68255;8 2 ". >B 2016 3.; 2 [4J@6020] 8<0; 2.; 0:> A5 2J@=5; 2 [4J@6020] IO; 40 8<0 ?@>1;5<8 70@048 2.; C. 4> H. :., => =5 ?><=5; C. A8; 18; <. =0 :.; 2. A8 A. >. >B 2011 4> 2015 3.; =5 5 18; G. =0 2. .; =5 2;870; 2J2 2. A 0. 8;8 ?. 2 @>4=0B0 A8 AB@0=0; =0?CA=0; 70@048 2. 8 ;8?A0 =0 5. C. 70 6., 0:> A5 2J@=5; 2 [4J@6020] 2 =53>28O @09>= 8<0;> 7. 70 6. =0 :., =. 38 70I>B> A0 2. <., A. 0., :>8B> A0 A. >. A5 >. <=>3> ;. :J< BOE, =5 38 8A:0;8; ;8G=> =5 5 18; A2845B5; =0 2. 4.; @5H8; 40 =0?CA=5 AB@0=0B0 A8, ?>@048 ;8?A0 =0 A., F5;B0 <C 18;0 40 >B845 2 =O:>O 4J@6020 8 40 A5 A. AJA A. A8; =5 8A:0 40 A5 2@JI0 2 [4J@6020], 70I>B> 8<0 2.; 8A:0; 40 ?>;CG8 70:@8;0 2 J;30@8O, 70 40 A5 A. AJA A. 8 4. A8; 2 B5;5D>=0 8<0; 4>:C<5=B, G5 5 [A5<59=> ?>;>65=85]. !J3;0A=> 2?8A0=>B> 2 ?@>B>:>;0, 8=B5@2NB> 5 >AJI5AB25=> G@57 2845> :>=D5@5=B=0 2@J7:0, :0B> 87@8G=> 5 ?>A>G5=> 2 45:;0@0B82=0B0 G0AB, G5 B5:ABJB 5 ?@52545= =0 GC645=5F0 =0 @0718@05< 70 =53> :. 5. 8 =5 A0 AJI5AB2C20;8 :><C=8:0B82=8 ?@5G:8, 4>1@5 @0718@0 A<8AJ;0 =0 =0?8A0=>B> 8 =O<0 2J7@065=8O ?> =53>. ;04H8 5:A?5@B 2 & – [=0A5;5=> <OAB>] ?@54AB028; ?@54 @54A540B5;O =0 !B0=>28I5 @53. ! #3825/17.07.2024 3., 2 :>5B> ?@54;>68; =0 GC645=5F0 40 A5 >B:065 ?@54>AB02O=5B> =0 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB. 0 16.08.2024 3. @54A540B5;OB =0 J@602=0 035=F8O 70 1560=F8B5 ?@8 ! ?>AB0=>28; 5H5=85 ! 8766, A :>5B> =0 >A=>20=85 G;. 75 0;. 1 B. 2 8 B. 4 >B # >B:070; ?@54>AB02O=5 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB =0 . . $.. 5H5=85B> 18;> 2@JG5=> =0 =53>28O 04@5A0B =0 27.08.2024 3., 0 60;10B0 A@5IC 0:B0, ?> :>OB> 5 >1@07C20=> =0AB>OI>B> AJ451=> ?@>872>4AB2> 18;0 45?>78@0=0 ?@54 04<8=8AB@0B82=8O >@30= =0 29.08.2024 3. > 4>:070B5;AB20B0 A0 ?@85B8 :0B> G0AB >B ?@5?8A:0B0 873>B25=8 >B 8@5:F8O &bdquo;564C=0@>4=0 459=>AB“ ?@8 !?@02:0 2E. ! &#-1558/01.07.2024 3. >B=>A=> >1I>B> ?>;>65=85 8 0:BC0;=0B0 >1I5AB25=>-?>;8B8G5A:0 >1AB0=>2:0 2 !. 0. @. 8 !?@02:0 2E. ! &#-1554/01.07.2024 3. >B=>A=> . [4J@6020] >B=>A=> >1I>B> ?>;>65=85 2 AB@0=0B0, >1I5AB25=>-?>;8B8G5A:0B0 >1AB0=>2:0, :0: B. 70:>=>40B5;AB2> @53;0<5=B8@0 8 70I8B020 ?@020B0 =0 1560=F8B5 2 [4J@6020], ?>;>65=85 =0 A. 1. 2 [4J@6020] 8 >B3>20@O ;8 ". =0 >?@545;5=85B> 70 &bdquo;B@5B0 A83C@=0 4J@6020“ >B=>A=> 3@0640=8B5 =0 [4J@6020], BJ@A5I8 <564C=0@>4=0 70:@8;0. J< 4>:070B5;AB20B0 5 ?@8>1I5=> 8 5H5=85 ! 247/03.04.2024 3. =0 8=8AB5@A:8 AJ25B =0 J;30@8O 70 ?@85<0=5 =0 !?8AJ: =0 A83C@=8 AB@0=8 =0 ?@>87E>4 8 =0 !?8AJ: =0 B@5B8 A83C@=8 AB@0=8 ?> >B=>H5=85 =0 BJ@A5I8B5 70:@8;0, AJ>1@07=> G85B> @8;>65=85 ! 2, . [4J@6020] 5 ?>A>G5=0 2 !?8AJ: =0 B@5B8 A83C@=8 AB@0=8 ?> >B=>H5=85 =0 BJ@A5I8B5 70:@8;0. >@=0B0 D0:B8G5A:0 >1AB0=>2:0 AJ4JB ?@85 70 CAB0=>25=0 2J7 >A=>20 =0 2A8G:8 AJ1@0=8 ?> 45;>B> ?8A<5=8 4>:070B5;AB20, =5>A?>@5=8 >B AB@0=8B5 ?> ?@542845=8O 2 70:>=0 @54. J7 >A=>20 =0 AJI0B0 AJ4JB D>@<8@0 A;54=8B5 ?@02=8 872>48: 0;10B0 5 ?@>F5AC0;=> 4>?CAB8<0, :0B> ?>4045=0 >B ;538B8<8@0=0 AB@0=0 – ?@8 =0;8G85 =0 ?@025= 8=B5@5A >B BJ@A5=0B0 70I8B0, A@5IC ?>4;560I =0 AJ4515= :>=B@>; 8=48284C0;5= 04<8=8AB@0B825= 0:B 8 ?@8 A?0720=5 =0 14 - 4=52=8O A@>: 70 AJ451=> >160;20=5, ?@542845= 2 G;. 84 0;. 3 >B #. 073;540=0 ?> AJI5AB2>, 60;10B0 A5 ?@5F5=O20 >B =0AB>OI0B0 AJ451=0 8=AB0=F8O :0B> =5>A=>20B5;=0 8 :0B> B0:020 A;5420 40 1J45 >BE2J@;5=0. !J>1@065=8OB0 =0 AJ40 2 B078 =0A>:0 A0 A;54=8B5: !;54 :0B> 5 A578@0= A >A?>@20=5, ?@8 A;C651=8O 8 FO;>AB5= :>=B@>; 2J@EC 70:>=>AJ>1@07=>ABB0 =0 >160;20=8O 04<8=8AB@0B825= 0:B, AJ3;0A=> =>@<0B0 =0 G;. 168 0;. 1 >B , AJ4JB ?@>25@8 87=0G0;=> =53>20B0 20;84=>AB. ">20 A5 =0;030 ?>@048 ?@8=F8?0 =0 A;C651=>B> =0G0;> 2 04<8=8AB@0B82=8O ?@>F5A, 2J2545= A =>@<0B0 =0 G;. 9 >B . A?>@5=>B> 2 =0AB>OI>B> ?@>872>4AB2> @5H5=85 5 ?>AB0=>25=> >B :><?5B5=B5= >@30= – @54A540B5;OB =0 , G8OB> <0B5@80;=0 :><?5B5=B=>AB 5 @53;0<5=B8@0=0 2 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;. 48 0;. 1 B. 1, ?@54;. 2B>@> >B #. A?>@5=8OB 0:B, :0B> 874045= >B <0B5@80;=> 8 ?5@A>=0;=> :><?5B5=B5= >@30= 8 2 ?@54?8A0=0B0 >B 70:>=0 ?@54<5B=0 D>@<0 8 AJ4J@60=85, AJ4JB ?@85<0 70 20;845=. 160;20=>B> @5H5=85 5 AJ>B25B=> 8 =0 >1I8B5 878A:20=8O 70 D>@<0 8 AJ4J@60=85 ?> G;. 59 >B , AJ4J@60 :0:B> D0:B8G5A:8, B0:0 8 ?@02=8 >A=>20=8O 70 =53>2>B> 874020=5, >1>A=>2020I8 :@09=>B> D>@<8@0=> 2>;587O2;5=85 70 >B:07 =0 >@30=0 40 ?@54>AB028 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB =0 60;1>?>40B5;O. A25= 20;84=>, 0B0:C20=>B> 04<8=8AB@0B82=> @5H5=85 A5 ?@5F5=O20 >B AJ40 8 :0B> 874045=> ?@8 A?0720=5 =0 2A8G:8 AJI5AB25=8 04<8=8AB@0B82=>?@>872>4AB25=8 ?@028;0 8 2 AJ>B25BAB285 A >B=>A8<8B5 <0B5@80;=>?@02=8 =>@<8. B AJ1@0=8B5 ?> 45;>B> ?8A<5=8 4>:070B5;AB20 - 04<8=8AB@0B82=0B0 ?@5?8A:0, ?@8:;NG8;0 A ?>AB0=>2O20=5 =0 >A?>@5=>B> @5H5=85 A5 CAB0=>2O20, G5 2 E>40 =0 ?@>872>4AB2>B> ?> >1I8O @54 ?@54 :><?5B5=B5= 8=B5@2N8@0I >@30= :J< J@602=0 035=F8O 70 1560=F8B5, A GC645=5F0 5 ?@>2545=> 8=B5@2N, >B@075=> 2 =0@>G5= ?@>B>:>;, 872J@H5=> >B >?@02><>I5=> 4;J6=>AB=> ;8F5, 2 ?@8AJAB285 =0 ?@52>40G 8 =0 578:, :>9B> <>;8B5;OB 70 70:@8;0 2;0455 – :.. 0;8F5 A0 8 :0B53>@8G=8 40==8, G5 AJ4J@60=85B> =0 ?@>B>:>;0 AJI> 5 ?@>G5B5=> =0 8=B5@2N8@0=8O 2 ?@8AJAB285B> =0 ?@52>40G0 8 =0 @0718@05<8O 70 =53> 578:, :0B> ?> >B@075=>B> $. 5 45:;0@8@0; ;8?A0 =0 :><C=8:0B82=8 ?@5G:8, :0:B> 8 G5 4>1@5 5 @071@0; A<8AJ;0 =0 =0?8A0=>B> 8 =O<0 2J7@065=8O ?> =53>. !?075=> 5 8 878A:20=5B> =0 G;. 58 0;. 10 >B #, :0B> 2 A;CG0O >B >B25B=8:0 5 878A:0=> ?8A<5=> AB0=>28I5 >B ! ?> <>;10B0 =0 60;1>?>40B5;O 70 ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 <564C=0@>4=0 70:@8;0, B0:>20 5 ?@54>AB025=> ?@548 ?@>87=0AO=5B> =0 >@30=0 8 A =53> >B AB@0=0 =0 ! =5 5 2J7@075=> ?> ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 AB0BCB ?@8 =0;8G85 =0 <0B5@80;=>?@02=8B5 ?@54?>AB02:8 2 ?@8;>68<8O 70:>=. @54?>AB02:8B5 70 ?@54>AB02O=5B> =0 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 =0 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB A0 @53;0<5=B8@0=8 >B 70:>=>40B5;O 2 G;. 8 8 G;. 9 >B #. =>@<0B0 =0 G;. 8 0;. 1 >B # A0 ?>A>G5=8 CA;>28OB0, ?@8 =0;8G85B> =0 :>8B> =0 GC645=5F A5 ?@54>AB02O AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 2 5?C1;8:0 J;30@8O – GC645=5FJB 40 5 872J= 4J@6020B0 A8 ?> ?@>87E>4 8 40 =5 <>65 8;8 =5 65;05 40 A5 ?>;720 >B 70:@8;0B0 =0 B078 4J@6020 8;8 40 A5 702J@=5 2 =5O ?> ?@8G8=8, A2J@70=8, >B 54=0 AB@0=0, A >A=>20B5;=> >?0A5=85 >B ?@5A;5420=5, 0 >B 4@C30 AB@0=0 – B>20 ?@5A;5420=5 40 5 ?>@048 =O:>5 >B 0;B5@=0B82=> 871@>5=8B5 E0@0:B5@8AB8:8 =0 AC15:B0: =53>20B0 @0A0, @5;838O, =0F8>=0;=>AB, ?>;8B8G5A:> <=5=85 8;8 ?@8=04;56=>AB :J< >?@545;5=0 A>F80;=0 3@C?0. 0;8G85B> 8 >A=>20B5;=>ABB0 =0 >?0A5=8OB0 A;5420 40 1J40B ?@5F5=5=8 A >3;54 ?@54AB025=8B5 2 1560=A:0B0 8AB>@8O =0 :0=4840B0 70 AB0BCB 40==8, :0B> A5 >BG5B5 ?@>87E>4JB =0 ?@5A;5420=5B>, 40;8 ?>A;54=>B> 2>48 4> =0@CH020=5 =0 >A=>2=8 ?@020 =0 G>25:0 8 70:@8;0B0, :>OB> <>65 40 1J45 ?>;CG5=0 >B 4J@6020B0 ?> ?@>87E>4. ?@>F5A=8O A;CG09 60;1>?>40B5;OB 5 @538AB@8@0= 2 & – [=0A5;5=> <OAB>] ?@8 :0B> A. 3., ?@54284 :>5B> 70 4J@6020 ?> ?@>87E>4 ?> A<8AJ;0 =0 § 1 B. 7 >B =0 # A;5420 40 A5 ?@85<5 !. 0. @.. =0AB>OI8O A;CG09 ?@028;=> 04<8=8AB@0B82=8OB >@30= 5 ?@5F5=8;, G5 ?@8 ?@>2545=>B> A 60;1>?>40B5;O 8=B5@2N =5 A5 CAB0=>2O20 A?@O<> ?>A;54=8O 40 5 >AJI5AB25=> 2878@0=>B> 2 G;. 8 0;. 1 >B # ?., @5;520=B=> 70 ?@54>AB02O=5B> =0 1560=A:8 AB0BCB =8B> 2 4J@6020B0 <C ?> ?@>87E>4, =8B> 2 . [4J@6020], :J45B> 5 ?@5182020; ?>A;54=8B5 8 3>48=8. 0;1>?>40B5;OB =5 70O2O20 :>=:@5B=8 >1AB>OB5;AB20, 2J7 >A=>20 =0 :>8B> 40 <>65 40 A5 =0?@028 872>4 70 >?0A5=85 >B ?., >A=>20=> =0 @., @., =., ?. <. 8;8 ?. <C :J< >?@545;5=0 A. 3@C?0. !J3;0A=> @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;. 8 0;. 4 >B #, ?@5A;5420=5 5 =0@CH020=5 =0 >A=>2=8B5 ?@020 =0 G>25:0 8;8 AJ2:C?=>AB >B 459AB28O, :>8B> 2>4OB 4> =0@CH020=5 =0 >A=>2=8B5 ?@020 =0 G>25:0, 4>AB0BJG=> B56:8 ?> A2>5B> 5AB5AB2> 8;8 ?>2B>@O5<>AB, 0 A?>@54 0;. 5 =0 AJI0B0 =>@<0, 459AB28OB0 =0 ?@5A;5420=5 <>30B 40 1J40B D878G5A:> 8;8 ?A8E8G5A:> =0A8;85, 70:>=>28, 04<8=8AB@0B82=8, ?>;8F59A:8 8;8 AJ451=8 <5@:8, :>8B> A0 48A:@8<8=0F8>==8 8;8 A5 ?@8;030B A F5; 48A:@8<8=0F8O. "2J@45=8O 70 ?>4>1=8 459AB28O =O<0 >15:B828@0=8 2 @07:070=0B0 >B 60;1>?>40B5;O 1560=A:0 8AB>@8O 8 =5 A5 CAB0=>2O20B ?> 45;>B>. @028;=0 5 ?@5F5=:0B0 =0 04<8=8AB@0B82=8O >@30=, G5 87;>65=8B5 >B :0=4840B0 <>B828 70 =0?CA:0=5 =0 AB@0=0B0 <C ?> ?@>87E>4 =5 A0 ?@02=> 7=0G8<8 70 BJ@A5=0B0 70I8B0, BJ9 :0B> =5 <>30B 40 A5 ?@85<0B 70 >1>A=>20=> >?0A5=85 >B ?@5A;5420=5. ">9 =5 5 70O28; A?@O<> =53> 40 5 18;> >AJI5AB25=> ?. >B 4J@6020, ?0@B88 8;8 >@30=870F88 8 =54J@602=8 AC15:B8 =8B> 2 AB@0=0B0 <C =0 ?@>87E>4 - [4J@6020], =8B> 2 AB@0=0B0, 2 :>OB> 5 ?@5182020; 2 ?@>4J;65=85 =0 8 3>48=8 A;54 B>20 - [4J@6020]. A=>2=8OB <>B82, :>9B> :0=4840BJB 70 70:@8;0 87BJ:20 70 =0?CA:0=5B> =0 [4J@6020], 5 2. 8 65;0=85 40 ?>;CG8 70:@8;0, 70 40 A5 AJ15@5 AJA A. 4. 8 1. A.. 0:0@ 8 04<8=8AB@0B82=8OB >@30= 40 ?@85<0 70 4>AB>25@=8 B578 AB@0E>25, ?@028;5= 5 872>4JB, G5 B578 ?@8B5A=5=8O =5 A0 ?@>48:BC20=8 >B @50;=8 459AB28O >B AB@0=0 =0 A. 0. 8 2;0AB. 0 ?@0:B8:0 ;8?A20B 459AB28O >B AB@0=0 =0 2;0AB8B5 8;8 4@C38 AC15:B8, 872J@H20I8 ?@5A;5420=5, 2878@0=8 2 G;. 8 0;. 3 >B #, >B :>8B> 40 A5 =0?@028 872>4 70 ?. 8;8 4. :J< A. 3.. ">9 =5 5 18; 7. 8 2J@EC =53> =5 5 18;> >. =., :0:B> 8 A0<8O B>9 70O2O20 2 8=B5@2NB> A8. !JI8OB =5 5 >. 8 =5 5 18; ?. >B >D8F80;=8B5 2;0AB8, =5 5 18; 7. 8;8 ?. ?> 5. 8;8 @. ?@8G8=8 =8B> 2 [4J@6020], =8B> 2 [4J@6020]. 0?@>B82 – 70O25=>B> >B =53> A>G8, G5 2>45I8OB <>B82 70 =0?CA:0=5 =0 AB@0=0B0 ?> ?@>87E>4 A0 2>45I8 A5 2. 4., 0 =0 ". B>78 <>B82 5 >B ;8G5= 8 8:>=><8G5A:8 E0@0:B5@. 0O25=0B0 1560=A:0 8AB>@8O A>G8, G5 $. 5 =0?CA=0; [4J@6020] =5 70 40 BJ@A8 C1568I5, 0 40 A5 AJ15@5 A 4. 8 1. A8 A.. 70O25=>B> >B :0=4840B0 70 C1568I5 =5 A5 AJ4J@60B B2J@45=8O 70 :>=:@5B=8 459AB28O =0 ?., 8;8 ?. A <0I01, 4>AB830I 3@0=8F0B0 =0 ?., =8B> 70 @8A: >B B0:>20 :0:B> 2 [4J@6020], B0:0 8 2 ".. @028;=> >@30=JB 5 ?@85; 70 =54>:070=> 8 =5>1>A=>20=> B2J@45=85B> =0 $., G5 5 =0?CA=0; [4J@6020], ?>@048 >?0A5=8O, G5 I5 1J45 4. 2 [4J@6020] 70@048 ;8?A0B0 =0 4>:C<5=B8. "578 A8 >?0A5=8O GC645=5FJB =5 ?>4:@5?O A 4>:070B5;AB20, =8B> 87;030 4>2>48, >1>A=>2020I8 B0:820. 0?@>B82, B>9 70O2O20, G5 4. <C A0 @. 2 ". 8 B5 8 1. <C A. ?@8B56020B 4>:C<5=B8 70 2@5<5==0 70:@8;0, 874045=8 B0<. 4=>2@5<5==> A B>20, 2 ?@>4J;65=85 =0 8 3>48=8 AJI8OB 68255 8 @. 2 [=0A5;5=> <OAB>], 18; 5 7. >B B. 2. ?@57 2019 3. ?@8 >?8B 40 ?@5<8=5 3@0=8F0B0 A [4J@6020], A;54 :>5B> 4> 2024 3. 5 ?@>4J;68; 157 ?@>1;5<8 682>B0 A8 B0<. !J3;0A=> ?@8;>65=0B0 ?> 45;>B> A?@02:0 70 >1I>B> ?>;>65=85 =0 A. 1. 2 "., A. 1. A5 @538AB@8@0B, ?>;CG020B 845=B8D8:0F8>==0 :0@B0 70 2@5<5==0 70:@8;0 8 @07?>;030B A 4>ABJ? 4> F5;8O =01>@ >B ?@020 8 CA;C38, 2 B.G. ?@02> =0 74@025>?0720=5, >1@07>20=85, 4>ABJ? 4> ?070@0 =0 B@C40, A>F80;=> ?>4?><030=5 8 4@., :0B> A. 1. A0 70I8B5=8 >B ?@8=C48B5;=> 2@JI0=5 2 [4J@6020]. 5I> ?>25G5 – . [4J@6020] 5 2:;NG5=0 2 >4>1@5= >B 8=8AB5@A:8 AJ25B =0 J;30@8O !?8AJ: =0 B@5B8 A83C@=8 AB@0=8 ?> >B=>H5=85 =0 BJ@A5I8B5 70:@8;0. "0:0 87;>65=>B> <>B828@0 =0AB>OI0B0 AJ451=0 8=AB0=F8O 40 ?@85<5, G5 5 ?@028;5= 8 70:>=>AJ>1@075= 872>4JB =0 04<8=8AB@0B82=8O >@30= 70 ;8?A0 =0 <0B5@80;=>?@02=8B5 ?@54?>AB02:8 70 ?@8;030=5 =0 G;. 8 >B # 70 ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F. >A56=> =0;8G85B> =0 ?@54?>AB02:8 70 ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB =0 GC645=5F0, A;5420 40 A5 >B15;568, G5 2 A;CG0O >B =53>20 AB@0=0 =5 A5 B2J@48 2 4J@6020B0 A8 =0 ?@>87E>4 8 4J@6020B0 [4J@6020] 40 5 8. =0 @50;=0 >. >B B. ?., :0B> A. =. 8;8 5., 8;8 8. 8;8 =. 8;8 C. >B=0AO=5, 8;8 =., :0:28B> 878A:20 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;. 9 0;. 1 B. 1 8 B. 2 >B #. O<0 8 =8:0:28 87;>65=8 B2J@45=8O 70 =0;8G85 =0 >1AB>OB5;AB20 :0B> ?@542845=8B5 2 G;. 9 0;. 6 8 0;. 8 >B #. 4<8=8AB@0B82=8OB >@30= 5 872J@H8; ?@5F5=:0 8 >B=>A=> <0B5@80;=>?@02=8B5 ?@54?>AB02:8 70 ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB ?> A<8AJ;0 =0 G;. 9 0;. 1 B. 3 >B #, AJ3;0A=> :>OB> =>@<0 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB A5 ?@54>AB02O =0 GC645=5F, :>9B> =5 >B3>20@O =0 878A:20=8OB0 70 ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 :>9B> =5 <>65 8;8 =5 65;05 40 ?>;CG8 70:@8;0 >B 4J@6020B0 A8 ?> ?@>87E>4, BJ9 :0B> <>65 40 1J45 87;>65= =0 @50;=0 >?0A=>AB >B B56:8 ?>A530B5;AB20, :0B>: B56:8 70?;0E8 A@5IC 682>B0 8;8 ;8G=>ABB0 =0 F828;=> ;8F5 ?>@048 157>3;54=> =0A8;85 2 A;CG09 =0 2J>@J65= <564C=0@>45= 8;8 2JB@5H5= :>=D;8:B. 0;8G85B> =0 B56:8 8 ;8G=8 70?;0E8 A@5IC 682>B0 8;8 ;8G=>ABB0 =0 F828;=> ;8F5 ?>@048 157>3;54=> =0A8;85 2 A;CG09 =0 2J>@J65= 2JB@5H5= 8;8 <564C=0@>45= :>=D;8:B 5 D>@<C;8@0=> :0B> B56:> ?>A530B5;AB2> 8 CA;>285 70 ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 AC1A8480@=0 70:@8;0 8 2 G;5= 15, 1C:20 "2" >B 8@5:B820 2004/83/ =0 !J25B0 >B 29 0?@8; 2004 3>48=0 >B=>A=> <8=8<0;=8B5 AB0=40@B8 70 ?@87=020=5B> 8 ?@02=>B> ?>;>65=85 =0 3@0640=8B5 =0 B@5B8 AB@0=8 8;8 ;8F0B0 157 3@0640=AB2> :0B> 1560=F8 8;8 :0B> ;8F0, :>8B> ?> 4@C38 ?@8G8=8 A5 =C640OB >B <564C=0@>4=0 70:@8;0, :0:B> 8 >B=>A=> AJ4J@60=85B> =0 ?@54>AB025=0B0 70:@8;0. !J3;0A=> 5H5=85 >B 17 D52@C0@8 2009 3. =0 !J40 =0 2@>?59A:8O !JN7 ?> 45;> C-465/07, G;5= 15, 1C:20 "2" >B 8@5:B820 2004/83/, 2J2 2@J7:0 A G;5= 2, 1C:20 "4" >B AJI0B0 8@5:B820, B@O120 40 A5 BJ;:C20 2 A<8AJ;, G5: AJI5AB2C20=5B> =0 B56:8 8 ;8G=8 70?;0E8 A@5IC 682>B0 8;8 ;8G=>ABB0 =0 <>;8B5;O 70 AC1A8480@=0 70:@8;0 =5 5 ?>4G8=5=> =0 CA;>285B> ?>A;54=8OB 40 ?@54AB028 4>:070B5;AB2>, G5 B>9 ?@54AB02;O20 A?5F8D8G=0 F5; ?>@048 ?@8AJI8 =0 =53>2>B> ;8G=> ?>;>65=85 5;5<5=B8; AJI5AB2C20=5B> =0 B0:820 70?;0E8 <>65 ?> 87:;NG5=85 40 A5 AG8B0 70 CAB0=>25=>, :>30B> AB5?5=B0 =0 E0@0:B5@878@0I>B> ?@>B8G0I8O 2J>@J65= :>=D;8:B 157>3;54=> =0A8;85, ?@5F5=O20=0 >B :><?5B5=B=8B5 =0F8>=0;=8 2;0AB8, A578@0=8 A <>;10 70 AC1A8480@=0 70:@8;0, 8;8 >B N@8A48:F88B5 =0 4J@6020 G;5=:0, ?@54 :>8B> A5 >160;20 @5H5=85 70 >BE2J@;O=5 =0 B0:020 <>;10, 4>AB830 B>;:>20 28A>:> =82>, G5 AJI5AB2C20B A5@8>7=8 8 ?>B2J@45=8 >A=>20=8O 40 A5 A<OB0, G5 F828;=> ;8F5, 2J@=0B> 2 AJ>B25B=0B0 AB@0=0, 8;8 525=BC0;=> 2 AJ>B25B=8O @538>=, ?>@048 A0<8O D0:B =0 ?@8AJAB285B> A8 =0 BOE=0B0 B5@8B>@8O A5 87;030 =0 @50;=0 >?0A=>AB 40 ?@5BJ@?8 ?>A>G5=8B5 70?;0E8. 4<8=8AB@0B82=8OB >@30= 5 872J@H8; ?@5F5=:0B0 A8 ?> ?@8;030=5 =0 G;. 9 0;. 1 B. 3 >B # 4>A56=> 4J@6020B0 =0 ?@>87E>4, :0B> 5 ?@85;, G5 =5 <>65 40 A5 >G0:20 :0=4840BJB 40 A5 CAB0=>28 2 4@C30 G0AB >B B5@8B>@8OB0 =0 4J@6020B0, :J45B> 40 A5 ?>;720 >B 70:@8;0, :>OB> 40 5 5D5:B82=0 8 A B@05= E0@0:B5@, :0B> ?@028;=>, A >3;54 D0:B8B5 5 ?@5F5=8; 1560=A:0B0 8AB>@8O =0 GC645=5F0 A >3;54 @07?8A0=>B> 2 G;. 75 0;. 2 >B # 8 >1AB>OB5;AB2>B>, G5 $. 5 ?@5182020; =0 B5@8B>@8OB0 =0 ". 2 ?@>4J;65=85 =0 >:>;> 8 3>48=8 8 2 =0AB>OI8O <><5=B A. <C A5 =0<8@0 B0<. !?>@54 70O25=>B> 2 1560=A:0B0 8AB>@8O ?> 2@5<5 =0 ?@5182020=5B> A8 B0< GC645=5FJB =5 5 8<0; >A=>20=8O 40 A5 >. 70 6. 8;8 A. A8 ?>@048 @., @., =., ?. :J< >?@545;5=0 A. 3@C?0 8;8 ?. <=5=85. 8?A20B B2J@45=8O >B GC645=5F0 40 5 18; ?. 40 A5 2J@=5 2 [4J@6020], =8B> 40 5 8<0; ?. A 2;0AB8B5, 40 5 18; 7., 8;8 A?@O<> =53> 40 5 >. =.. ! 87;>65=8 ?>4@>1=8 872>48, :>8B> A5 A?>45;OB 87FO;> >B AJ40, :0B> AJ>B25B=8 =0 4>:070B5;AB20B0, 04<8=8AB@0B82=8OB >@30= 5 ?@85;, G5 A0 =0;8F5 2A8G:8 :C<C;0B82=> 878A:C5<8 >B @07?>@5410B0 =0 § 1 B. 9 >B =0 # ?@54?>AB02:8 4J@6020B0 [4J@6020], 2 :>OB> 5 ?@5182020; 60;1>?>40B5;OB A;54 =0?CA:0=5B> =0 [4J@6020], 40 A5 ?@85<5 70 B@5B0 A83C@=0 4J@6020 ?> >B=>H5=85 =0 :0=4840B0 70 70:@8;0. !J3;0A=> § 1 B. 9 >B =0 #, ""@5B0 A83C@=0 4J@6020" 5 4J@6020, @07;8G=0 >B 4J@6020B0 ?> ?@>87E>4, 2 :>OB> GC645=5FJB, ?>40; <>;10 70 <564C=0@>4=0 70:@8;0, 5 ?@5182020; 8: 0) =O<0 >A=>20=8O 40 A5 >?0AO20 70 682>B0 8;8 A2>1>40B0 A8 ?>@048 @0A0, @5;838O, =0F8>=0;=>AB, ?@8=04;56=>AB :J< >?@545;5=0 A>F80;=0 3@C?0 8;8 ?>;8B8G5A:> <=5=85; 1) 5 70I8B5= >B 2@JI0=5 4> B5@8B>@8OB0 =0 4J@6020, 2 :>OB> AJI5AB2C20B CA;>28O 70 ?@5A;5420=5 8 70AB@0H020=5 =0 ?@020B0 <C; 2) =5 5 87;>65= =0 >?0A=>AB >B ?@5A;5420=5 8;8 B56:> ?>A530B5;AB2>, :0B> 87B570=85, =5G>25H:> 8;8 C=878B5;=> >B=0AO=5, 8;8 =0:070=85; 3) AJI5AB2C20 2J7<>6=>AB 40 ?>8A:0 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 ?@8 ?@54>AB02O=5B> <C 40 A5 ?>;720 >B <564C=0@>4=0 70:@8;0 :0B> 1560=5F; 4) A0 =0;8F5 4>AB0BJG=> >A=>20=8O 40 A5 A<OB0, G5 I5 1J45 4>?CA=0B 4> B5@8B>@8OB0 =0 B078 4J@6020. B AJ1@0=8B5 ?> 45;>B> ?8A<5=8 4>:070B5;AB20, 2:;NG8B5;=> >B 70O25=>B> >B :0=4840B0 70 70:@8;0 2 ?@>2545=>B> 8=B5@2N <>65 40 A5 =0?@028 872>40, G5 AJI8O =O<0 >A=>20=8O 40 A5 >. 70 6. 8;8 A. A8 ?>@048 @., @., =., ?. :J< >?@545;5=0 A. 3@C?0 8;8 ?. <=5=85, =5 5 8. =0 >. >B ?. 8;8 B. ?., :0B> 8., =. 8;8 C. >B=0AO=5, 8;8 =.. ! >3;54 40==8B5, AJ4J@60I8 A5 2 ?@85B0B0 A?@02:0 >B=>A=> . [4J@6020], A;5420 40 A5 ?@85<5, G5 2 B078 AB@0=0 60;1>?>40B5;OB 18 18; 70I8B5= >B 2@JI0=5 4> B5@8B>@8OB0 =0 AB@0=0B0 A8 ?> ?@>87E>4. 4<8=8AB@0B82=8OB >@30= 5 872J@H8; ?@5F5=:0 :0:B> =0 87;>65=0B0 1560=A:0 8AB>@8O, B0:0 8 =0 A83C@=>ABB0 2 B078 4J@6020, 0=0;878@0=0 2 ?>A>G5=0B0 A?@02:0 8 ?@028;=> 5 CAB0=>28;, G5 [4J@6020] A5 O2O20 B@5B0 A83C@=0 4J@6020 70 :0=4840B0, :0B> B>9 <>65 40 ?>8A:0 8 ?>;CG8 70:@8;0 >B B. 2.. ?>4:@5?0 =0 B>20 5 8 70O25=>B> >B $., G5 ?@57 3>48=8B5, 2 :>8B> 5 682O; B0< =5 5 18; ?. 40 =. 8 40 A5 702J@=5 2 [4J@6020], 2 :>OB> =0A>:0 87@07O20 548=AB25=> >?0A5=8O. 0:B> A5 >B15;O70 ?> – 3>@5, >B A?@02:0B0, :0A05I0 [4J@6020] A5 CAB0=>2O20, G5 =0 B5@8B>@8OB0 =0 4J@6020B0 =O<0 2J>@J65= :>=D;8:B 4> AB5?5= =0 87:;NG8B5;=> 8 157>3;54=> =0A8;85, 0 ?> >B=>H5=85 =0 1560=F8B5 A5 ?@54>AB02O @568< =0 2@5<5==0 70:@8;0, :0B> :0=4840B8B5 ?>;CG020B 845=B8D8:0F8>==0 :0@B0 70 2@5<5==0 70:@8;0 8 @07?>;030B A 4>ABJ? 4> F5;8O =01>@ >B ?@020 8 CA;C38, :0:B> 8: &bdquo;A8G:8 A. 1. 2 [4J@6020] A0 70I8B5=8 >B ?@8=C48B5;=> 2@JI0=5 2 [4J@6020].“. !J3;0A=> G;. 21 B. 7 >B #AB@>9AB25= ?@028;=8: =0 J@602=0 035=F8O 70 1560=F8B5 ?@8 8=8AB5@A:8 AJ25B, 8@5:F8O &bdquo;564C=0@>4=0 459=>AB“ 873>B2O 8 0:BC0;878@0 0=0;8B8G=8 4>:;048 8 A?@02:8 70 A83C@=8B5 4J@6028 ?> ?@>87E>4, 70 B@5B8B5 A83C@=8 4J@6028, 70 :@878A=8B5 @09>=8 8 70 1560=A:8B5 ?>B>F8. !;54>20B5;=> F8B8@0=0B0 A?@02:0 5 873>B25=0 >B :><?5B5=B5= >@30= 8 2 :@J30 =0 ?@02><>I8OB0 <C, ?>@048 :>5B> ?@54AB02;O20 >D8F80;5= ?8A<5= A2845B5;AB20I 4>:C<5=B, C4>AB>25@O20I, G5 ;8F5B>, :>5B> 3> 5 8740;>, ?@8 872J@H5=0B0 >B =53> ?@>25@:0 5 CAB0=>28;> 8<5==> D0:B8B5, C4>AB>25@5=8 2 4>:C<5=B0. A25B;8=0B0 =0 AJ1@0=0B0 8=D>@<0F8O 70 . [4J@6020] A;5420 40 A5 2J7?@85<5 872>40, G5 =0 B5@8B>@8OB0 =0 B078 AB@0=0 :0=4840BJB 70 70:@8;0 2 :>=:@5B=8O A;CG09 =5 18 8<0; >A=>20=8O 40 A5 >. 70 6. 8;8 A. A8 ?>@048 @., @., =., ?. :J< >?@545;5=0 A. 3@C?0 8;8 ?. <.. 1560=A:0B0 8AB>@8O =5 A0 87;>65=8 =8:0:28 4>2>48, :>8B> 40 A>G0B ?>4>1=8 >A=>20=8O, =0?@>B82 - AB020 OA=>, G5 :0=4840BJB 5 ?@5182020; 2 ?@>4J;65=85 =0 8 3>48=8 2 [4J@6020], :J45B> 5 ?. B., 0 B2J@45=85B> <C, G5 =5 <C 5 18; 874045= 4>:C<5=B, :0:B> ?@028;=> 5 ?@85; >B25B=8OB >@30=, 5 =5>1>A=>20=>, ?>@048 70O25=>B>, G5 4>:C<5=B8 70 2@5<5==> ?@5182020=5 A0 18;8 874045=8 =0 4. <C 8 1. <C A.. I5 ?>25G5, G5 70O2O20, G5 ?@57 2019 3. 5 18; 7. >B B. 2. ?@8 >?8B 40 ?@5<8=5 =5;530;=> 3@0=8F0B0 A [4J@6020], A. A0 <C ?. >., => A?@O<> =53> =5 A0 ?@54?@85B8 =8:0:28 459AB28O, 2<5AB> :>5B> B>9 A5 5 702J@=0; 2 [=0A5;5=> <OAB>] 8 5 ?@>4J;68; 40 @. =0 ?@548H=0B0 A8 <.. =0;>38G=8 AJ>1@065=8O A;5420 40 A5 87;>60B 8 ?> >B=>H5=85 =0 ;8?A0B0 =0 >. >B ?. 8;8 B. ?., :0B> 8., =. 8;8 C. >B=0AO=5, 8;8 =.. 70O25=0B0 1560=A:0 8AB>@8O ;8?A20B B2J@45=8O, G5 :0=4840BJB 5 18; ?. =0 ?>4>1=8 ?., :>5B> A5 ?>4:@5?O 8 >B ?@54AB025=0B0 A?@02:0 70 ". 2 G0ABB0 9 4>A56=> AB0BCB0 =0 A. 1., 0 ?>A;54=8B5 A0 70I8B5=8 A@5IC ?@8=C48B5;=> 2@JI0=5 2 [4J@6020], :0B> 8< A5 ?@54>AB02O 4>ABJ? 4> 74@025>?0720=5, A>F80;=> ?>4?><030=5, >1@07>20=85 8 ?070@0 =0 B@C40. !0<8OB :0=4840B 70 70:@8;0 $. AJI> A>G8, G5 5 @., 4>:0B> 5 ?@5182020; 2 [4J@6020]. J7 >A=>20 =0 B>20 8 >A5<3>48H=8O 157?@5?OBAB25= ?@5AB>9 =0 ;8F5B> 2 [4J@6020], >A=>20B5;=> <>65 40 A5 >G0:20 B> 40 A5 702J@=5 8 40 1J45 ?@85B> 2 B078 AB@0=0. :BC0;=0B0 8=D>@<0F8O 70 [4J@6020], 4>ABJ?=0 8 =0 8=B5@=5B AB@0=8F8B5 =0 8 2@>?59A:0B0 035=F8O 70 ?>4:@5?0 2 >1;0ABB0 =0 C1568I5B>, A :>OB> =0F8>=0;=8B5 AJ48;8I0 A0 4;J6=8 40 A5 AJ>1@07OB, AJ3;0A=> G;. 10, § 3, 1. "1" >B 8@5:B820 2013/32 AJI> =5 4020 >A=>20=85 70 AJ<=5=85 2 ?>-3>@5 87;>65=8B5 ?>;>65=8O ?> >B=>H5=85 =0 A., =0 :>8B> 25G5 5 ?@54>AB025=0 70:@8;0, :0:J2B> 5 A;CG0OB =0 =0AB>OI8O :0=4840B. @8 ?>AB0=>2O20=5 =0 A2>5B> @5H5=85 >@30=JB 5 87?J;=8; 704J;65=85B> A8, @53;0<5=B8@0=> 2 G;. 75 0;. 2 >B # ?@8 ?@>87=0AO=5 ?> <>;10B0 70 AB0BCB 40 ?@5F5=8 2A8G:8 >B=>A8<8 D0:B8, A2J@70=8 A ;8G=>B> ?>;>65=85 =0 <>;8B5;O, A 4J@6020B0 <C ?> ?@>87E>4 8;8 A 2J7<>6=>ABB0 40 A5 ?>;720 >B 70:@8;0B0 =0 4@C30 4J@6020. 72J@H5=0B0 ?@5F5=:0 70 ;8?A0 =0 >A=>20=8O 60;1>?>40B5;OB 40 A5 >. 70 6. 8;8 A. A8 =0 B078 B5@8B>@8O ?>@048 @., @., =., ?. :J< >?@545;5=0 A. 3@C?0 8;8 ?. <., :0:B> 8 G5 =5 5 8. =0 >. >B ?. 8;8 B. ?., :0B> 8., =. 8;8 C. >., 8;8 =., 8 G5 70 :0=4840B0 5 2J7<>6=> 40 A5 702J@=5 2 [4J@6020], =5 A5 >?@>25@3020 >B >AB0=0;8B5 AJ1@0=8 ?> 45;>B> 4>:070B5;AB20. "2J@45=85B> =0 60;1>?>40B5;O, G5 ?@8 ?@>2545=>B> 8=B5@2N G@57 2845>2@J7:0 A0 18;8 =0;8F5 ?@5:JA20=8O, ?>@048 :>5B> =5?@028;=> 18;> 2J7?@85B> >B >@30=0, G5 B>9 5 ?@5182020; 2 [4J@6020] 8 3>48=8, 0 @50;=> ?5@8>4JB 5 18; 8 <5A5F0, A5 >?@>25@3020 87FO;> >B AJ4J@60=85B> =0 ?@>B>:>;0 >B ?@>2545=>B> 8=B5@2N. J@2>, 2 AJI8O &bdquo;8 3>48=8“ A0 A?><5=0B8 A0<> 254=J6, :0B> 54=>2@5<5==> A B>20 =5:>;:>:@0B=> :0=4840BJB A>G8 2015 3. :0B> B0:020, ?@57 :>OB> =5;530;=> 5 2;O7J; 2 . [4J@6020], 2019 3. 5 >?8B0; 40 ?@5<8=5 3@0=8F0B0 A [4J@6020], A;54 :>5B> A5 5 702J@=0; 8 5 ?@>4J;68; 40 @. =0 AJI0B0 <., OA=> 5 70O28; >I5, G5 2 ?5@8>40 >B 2015 3>48=0 4> 2024 5 @. 2 [=0A5;5=> <OAB>]. 5I> ?>25G5, A;54 ?@>G8B0 =0 AJ4J@60=85B> =0 ?@>B>:>;0, $. 5 45:;0@8@0;, G5 B5:ABJB <C 5 ?@52545= =0 @0718@05< 70 =53> :. 5. 8 =5 A0 AJI5AB2C20;8 :><C=8:0B82=8 ?@5G:8, 4>1@5 @0718@0 =0?8A0=>B> 8 =O<0 2J7@065=8O ?> =53>. > 87;>65=8B5 AJ>1@065=8O =0AB>OI0B0 AJ451=0 8=AB0=F8O ?@85<0, G5 5H5=85 ! 8766/16.08.2024 3., 874045=> >B @54A540B5;O =0 J@602=0 035=F8O 70 1560=F8B5 ?@8 !, A :>5B> 5 ?>AB0=>25= >B:07 70 ?@54>AB02O=5 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB =0 . . $., [4J@6020] 5 ?>AB0=>25=0 ?@8 A?0720=5 =0 2A8G:8 AJI5AB25=8 04<8=8AB@0B82=>?@>872>4AB25=8 ?@028;0, 2 AJ>B25BAB285 A >B=>A8<8B5 8 ?@8;>68<8 <0B5@80;=>?@02=8 =>@<8 8 A F5;B0 =0 70:>=0. ! >3;54 87;>65=>B>, AJ4JB AG8B0, G5 >A?>@5=>B> @5H5=85 AJ>B25BAB20 =0 2A8G:8 878A:20=8O 70 70:>=>AJ>1@07=>AB, ?>@048 :>5B> ?>4045=0B0 A@5IC =53> 60;10 A;5420 40 1J45 >BE2J@;5=0 :0B> =5>A=>20B5;=0.   >48< >B 3>@=>B> 8 =0 >A=>20=85 G;. 172 0;. 2 >B , AJ4JB     ( :     "%* / 60;10B0 =0 . . $., A ' .............., [4J@6020], A 04@5A & – [=0A5;5=> <OAB>] =0 ?@8 ! A@5IC 5H5=85 ! 8766/16.08.2024 3. =0 @54A540B5;O =0 J@602=0B0 035=F8O 70 1560=F8B5 ?@8 8=8AB5@A:8 AJ25B, A :>5B> =0 60;1>?>40B5;O 5 >B:070=> ?@54>AB02O=5 =0 AB0BCB =0 1560=5F 8 EC<0=8B0@5= AB0BCB.   5H5=85B> ?>4;568 =0 :0A0F8>==> >160;20=5 ?@54 J@E>2=8O 04<8=8AB@0B825= AJ4 =0 5?C1;8:0 J;30@8O 2 14-4=525= A@>: >B AJ>1I020=5B> <C =0 AB@0=8B5.     </div>    <div class="BreakerSignature" dir="ltr" style="margin: 30px 0 200px 0;"> <table border="0" class="body-text" dir="ltr" style="width: 100%;"> <tbody> <tr> <td style="text-align: right; vertical-align: top;">!J48O: </td> <td style="width: 205px;"> </td> </tr> <tr> <td style="text-align: right; vertical-align: top;padding-top: 20px"> </td> <td style="width: 205px;padding-top: 20px"> </td> </tr> </tbody> </table> </div>

Номер на акта:	1790
Дата:	4 октомври 2024 г.
Съдия:

Дело:	20247220700456
Тип на делото:	Административно дело
Дата на образуване:	5 септември 2024 г.

Решение по адм. дело №456/2024 на Административен съд - Сливен

Съдържание на акта