Решение по КНАХД №1111/2024 на Административен съд - Варна

юя<style type="text/css">.body-text { font-size:12pt !important; } </style> ( <5@">! 689 0@=0, 20.01.2025 3. " 4<8=8AB@0B82=8OB AJ4 - 0@=0 - I B@8G;5=5= AJAB02, 2 AJ451=> 70A540=85 =0 4525B8 O=C0@8 425 E8;O48 42045A5B 8 ?5B0 3>48=0 2 AJAB02: <table border="0" class="body-text" dir="ltr" style="width: 100%; margin: 40px 0px 40px;"> <tbody> <tr> <td style="text-align: right;">@54A540B5;: </td> <td style="text-align: left; vertical-align: top; width:300px;"> /</td> </tr> <tr> <td style="text-align: right; vertical-align: top;">25">';5=>25: </td> <td style="text-align: left; vertical-align: top; width:300px;">" ! " </td> </tr> </tbody> </table> @8 A5:@5B0@ " :C@>@0"> 8 A CG0AB85B> =0 ?@>:C@>@0 !/ !"/B AJ48O"> :0B> @073;540 4>:;0420=>B> >B AJ48O ! " 284 45;> =><5@"> :0=4 ! 20247050701111 / 2024 3., 70 40 A5 ?@>87=5A5 275 ?@54284 A;54=>B>:  <div class="rtf" dir="ltr" style="margin-bottom:.2pt;text-indent:35.45pt;font-size:12pt;font-family:MS Sans Serif; text-align: justify;"> @>872>4AB2>B> 5 ?> @540 =0 G;.208 8 A;. >B 4<8=8AB@0B82=>?@>F5AC0;=8O :>45:A //, 2@. G;.632 >B 0:>=0 70 04<8=8AB@0B82=8B5 =0@CH5=8O 8 =0:070=8O //. 1@07C20=> 5 ?> :0A0F8>==0 60;10 =0 35=F8O &bdquo;JB=0 8=D@0AB@C:BC@0“, #!"": ***, [=0A5;5=> <OAB>], G@57 N@:.!. !., ?@>B82 5H5=85 ! 93/25.03.20243. =0 09>=5= AJ4 - 52=O / !/, -B8 AJAB02, ?>AB0=>25=> ?> % ! 334/20233. ?> >?8A0 =0 AJI8O AJ4, A :>5B> 5 >B<5=5= $ ! **********, A :>9B> 70 =0@CH5=85 =0 G;.102, 0;.2 2 8 =0 >A=>20=85 G;.1870, 0;.2, B.3, 2@. G;.179, 0;.31 2, =0 &bdquo; # .!“ , ***5 =0;>65=0 8<CI5AB25=0 A0=:F8O, 2 @07<5@ =0 2500,00;2., 8 2 ?>;70 =0 4@C65AB2>B> A0 ?@8AJ45=8 @07=>A:8, 2 @07<5@ =0 660,00;2. 0A0B>@JB B2J@48 =5?@028;=>AB =0 >160;20=>B> @5H5=85 ?> AJ>1@065=8O 70 =5?@028;=> ?@8;>65=85 =0 <0B5@80;=8O 70:>= 8 4>?CA=0B8 AJI5AB25=8 ?@>F5AC0;=8 =0@CH5=8O - :0A0F8>==8 >A=>20=8O ?> G;.348, 0;.1, B.1 . >=:@5B=> A>G8, G5 ! =5 5 >?@545;8; ?@8;>68<8B5 ?> 45;>B> D0:B8 8 <0:0@ 40 5 ?@85; 70 4>:070=0 2J72545=0B0 A $ D0:B8G5A:0 >1AB0=>2:0, =5 5 <>B828@0; B078 G0AB >B @5H5=85B> A8. ! =5?@028;=> 5 BJ;:C20; 8 ?@8;>68; >B=>A8<8B5 :J< A;CG0O ?@02=8 =>@<8 8 =5 5 ?@8;>68; 70:>=0, :>9B> 5 B@O120;> 40 1J45 ?@8;>65=. >7>2020 A5 =0 <>B828B5 :J< 70:>=>?@>5:B0 70 87<5=5=85 =0 2 8 A>G8, G5 >B 8AB>@8G5A:>B> 8 DC=:F8>=0;=>B> BJ;:C20=5 =0 G;.1896, 0;.1 2 A;5420 872>4, G5 459AB28B5;=0B0 2>;O =0 70:>=>40B5;O 157 AJ<=5=85 5 40 1J45 AJ74045= ?@>F5AC0;5= @54 70 874020=5 =0 5;5:B@>==8 D8H>25 70 =0@CH5=8OB0, A2J@70=8 A =570?;0I0=5 =0 ?JB=8 B0:A8, 2:;. 8 70 874020=5 =0 $ 70 =0@CH5=8OB0 ?> G;.179, 0;.30 8 0;.31 2. >7>2020 A5 =0 5H5=85 ! 100/04.05.20063. =0 ! ?> =.4. ! 713/20153., A?>@54 :>5B>, :>30B> 2 B5:AB0 =0 =>@<0B825= 0:B 5 4>?CA=0B> =5AJ>B25BAB285 <564C 2>;OB0 =0 AJ740B5;O =0 =>@<0B0 8 =59=8OB 2J=H5= 87@07, :>OB> =57028A8<> >B ?@>87E>40 9, ?>@0640 =5OA=>B0, BO =0 >1I> >A=>20=85 ?>4;568 =0 >BAB@0=O20=5 ?> ?JBO =0 BJ;:C20=5B>. B=>A=> 872>4JB =0 ! - G5 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.179, 0;.31 2 =5 AJ>B25BAB20 =0 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.90 >B 8@5:B820 62/1999/ 70@048 878A:20=5B> 70 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>AB =0 =0:070=85B>, B2J@48, G5 ! 5 >B=5; 01A>;NB=0B0 :><?5B5=B=>AB =0 !! ?> 0@3. >B G;.267 $! 40 A5 ?@>87=0AO ?> 0:B>25, A2J@70=8 A BJ;:C20=5 =0 ?@02>B> =0 ! 8 A0<, 8718@09:8 A8 54=0 4C<0 >B 48@5:B820B0, >B<5=O CAB0=>25=0B0 AJA 70:>= A8AB5<0 >B =0:070=8O. B45;=> A>G8, G5 =0 ! <C 5 18;> 8725AB=> >1@07C20=>B> ?@54 !! 45;> !-61/23 ?> BJ;:C20=5B> =0 G;.90 >B 8@5:B820B0, ?>@048 :>5B> 5 A;5420;> 40 A?@5 45;>B>, 4> ?@8:;NG20=5 =0 ?@>872>4AB2>B> ?@54 !!. "2J@48 8 G5 ! =5 5 >BG5; A?5F8D8:0B0 =0 =0F8>=0;=0B0 A8AB5<0 >B =0:070=8O 2J2 2@J7:0 A =587?J;=5=85 =0 704J;65=8OB0 ?> 0:>=0 70 ?JB8I0B0, :>OB> ?>72>;O20 >A2>1>64020=5B> >B 04<8=8AB@0B82=>=0:070B5;=0 >B3>2>@=>AB ?@8 70?;0I0=5 =0 :><?5A0B>@=0 B0:A0 ?> G;.10, 0;.2 , :>OB> A?>@54 @07;8G=8B5 :0B53>@88 ! 5 2 ?JB8 ?>-<0;J: @07<5@ >B 01A>;NB=8O B0:J2 70 3;>18B5/8<CI5AB25=8B5 A0=:F88 ?> G;.179, 0;.3-31 2. > 87;>65=8B5 AJ>1@065=8O 8A:0 >B<O=0 =0 >160;20=>B> @5H5=85 8 ?>AB0=>2O20=5 =0 4@C3>, A :>5B> 40 A5 ?>B2J@48 $. @5B5=48@0 ?@8AJ640=5 =0 N@8A:>=AC;BA:> 2J7=03@0645=85. A;CG09 G5 60;10B0 =5 1J45 C2065=0 8 >B >B25B=8:0 A5 ?@5B5=48@0 042>:0BA:> 2J7=03@0645=85, ?@028 2J7@065=85 70 ?@5:><5@=>AB. B25B=0B0 AB@0=0 - &bdquo; # .!“ , G@57 042.. ., >A?>@20 :0A0F8>==0B0 60;10 ?> AJ>1@065=8O 2 ?8A<5=8 2J7@065=8O 2E. ! 3134/15.05.20243. 8 AB0=>28I5 !.4. ! 19381/19.12.20243. >;8 60;10B0 40 A5 >BE2J@;8 :0B> =5>A=>20B5;=0. @5B5=48@0 ?@8AJ640=5 =0 @07=>A:8 70 :0A0F8>==0B0 8=AB0=F8O. @54AB028B5;OB =0 :@J6=0 ?@>:C@0BC@0 - 0@=0, 4020 70:;NG5=85 70 =5>A=>20B5;=>AB =0 :0A0F8>==0B0 60;10. 0A0F8>==0B0 60;10 5 ?>4045=0 >B =04;56=0 AB@0=0, 2 70:>==8O A@>: ?>@048 :>5B> 5 #!". 073;540=0 ?> AJI5AB2>, 60;10B0 5 !". B D0:B8G5A:0 AB@0=0 ! 5 ?@85; 70 CAB0=>25=>, G5 2 11:33 G0A0 =0 23.03.20213., A CAB@>9AB2> ! 10072 - 5;5<5=B >B 5;5:B@>==0 A8AB5<0 70 AJ18@0=5 =0 ?JB=8 B0:A8 ?> G;.10, 0;.1 >B , =0<8@0I> A5 =0 ?JB -2 :<.399+703, A ?>A>:0 =0<0;O20I :8;><5BJ@ 2 1I8=0 - 52=O, >1;.0@=0, 2:;NG5= 2 >1E20B0 =0 ?;0B5=0B0 ?JB=0 <@560, 18;> CAB0=>25=> (70A=5B>) =0@CH5=85 A ! - 02B>1CA &bdquo;B>:0@ 5:B8> 310 "“ A @53. ! [@53. =><5@] - A>1AB25=>AB =0 &bdquo; # .!“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uro-Team 8 Spiral-Gep, !-497/15 5 !-498/15, :0:B> 8 =0 5H5=85 ?> 45;> !-384/17, 8 5 ?@85;, G5 ?@8=F8?JB =0 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>AB 5 704J;68B5;5= 70 4J@6028B5 G;5=:8 =5 A0<> 4> >?@545;O=5B> =0 AJAB020 =0 =0@CH5=85B> 8 =0 ?@028;0B0 >B=>A=> B565ABB0 =0 A0=:F88B5, => 8 4> ?@5F5=:0 =0 5;5<5=B8B5, :>8B> <>30B 40 1J40B >BG8B0=8 ?@8 >?@545;O=5 B> =0 @07<5@0 8<. 725; 5 872>4, G5 2 A;CG0O B578 CA;>28O =5 A0 87?J;=5=8 ?@8 ?@85<0=5 =0 =0F8>=0;=8B5 A0=:F8>==8 @07?>@5418 8 ?>-:>=:@5B=> =0 G;.179, 0;.31 2 8 G;.1870, 0;.2, B.1, 2 8 3 2, :>8B> ?@5428640B A0=:F88 2 01A>;NB5= @07<5@ - :>=:@5B=> 70 ?@>F5A=>B> =0@CH5=85 2500,00;2., :0B> =5 4020B =8:0:20 2J7<>6=>AB ?@8 =0;030=5B> 8< 40 A5 >BG8B0B A<5:G020I8 8;8 >B53G020I8 >B3>2>@=>ABB0 >1AB>OB5;AB20, :0:B> 8 40 1J40B ?@5F5=O20=8 @07;8G=8 5;5<5=B8 - =0?@8<5@ 87<8=0B> @07AB>O=85 2 =0@CH5=85 =0 878A:20=5B> 70 70?;0I0=5 =0 B>; B0:A8, @07<5@ =0 =5?;0B5=0B0 B0:A0, ?@8G8=8, ?>@048 :>8B> B0:A0B0 =5 5 70?;0B5=0, ?>@54=>AB =0 =0@CH5=85B> 8 B.=. !J>1@078; 5, G5 >I5 A @5H5=85 ?> 45;>B> Urban, !-210/10, B.41 !J4JB =0 ! 5 ?>AB0=>28;, G5 =0;030=5B> =0 A0=:F8O A D8:A8@0= @07<5@ 70 2AO:> =0@CH5=85 =0 ?@028;0B0 >B=>A=> >?@545;5=8 ?@542845=8 2 70:>=0 704J;65=8O, 157 40 A5 ?@5428640 @07;8G5= @07<5@, 2 7028A8<>AB >B B565ABB0 =0 872J@H5=>B> =0@CH5=85, 873;5640 =5?@>?>@F8>=0;=> A >3;54 =0 F5;8B5, ?>A>G5=8 2 ?@02=0B0 C@5410 =0 !JN70. >7>20209:8 A5 =0 5H5=8O =0 !! ?> 45;0 !-184/15 8 !-197/15, !-616/16 8 !-617/16, !-187/15 8 !-2/17, 8 4>:>;:>B> @07?>@5418B5 =0 G;.179, 0;.31 2 8 G;.1870, 0;.2, B.1, 2 8 3 2, =5 4>?CA:0B 872J@H20=5B> =0 ?@5F5=:0 >B=>A=> B565ABB0 =0 A0=:F88B5 8 =0 5;5<5=B8B5, :>8B> <>30B 40 1J40B >BG8B0=8 ?@8 >?@545;O=5 =0 B5E=8O @07<5@, 0 ?@5428640B 3;>18 8 8<CI5AB25=8 A0=:F88 2 01A>;NB5= @07<5@, 8 4>:>;:>B> 2 ?@02><>I8OB0 8 :><?5B5=F88B5 =0 AJ40 =5 A5 2:;NG20 >?@545;O=5B> =0 ?>4E>4OI A0=:F8>=5= @568<, 0 A0<> ?@8;030=5 =0 ?@85B8O B0:J<, =5 5 2J7<>6=> BJ;:C20=5 =0 =0F8>=0;=8O 70:>= ?> =0G8=, :>9B> 30@0=B8@0 ?J;=0B0 5D5:B82=>AB =0 ?@02>B> =0 ! 8 70I8B020 ?@54>AB025=8B5 =0 G0AB=8B5 AC15:B8 ?@020, 5 =5?@>?>@F8>=0;=0B0 A0=:F8>==0 C@5410 - G;.179, 0;.31 2 8 G;.1870, 0;.2, B.3 2, 40 1J45 >AB025=0 157 ?@8;>65=85, B.:. 2 ?@>B825= A;CG09 18 A5 AB83=0;> 4> =5AJ>B25BAB20I =0 ?@02>B> =0 !JN70 @57C;B0B. @8 ?@>25@:0B0 40;8 AJI5AB2C20 >1I0 04<8=8AB@0B82=>=0:070B5;=0 @07?>@5410, :>OB> ?@5428640 =0;030=5B> =0 A0=:F88 70 =0@CH5=8O =0 2, 70 :>8B> =5 5 ?@542845=0 4@C30 A0=:F8O, ! 5 CAB0=>28;, G5 B0:020 ;8?A20 8 G5 548=AB25=0B0 B0:020 5 B078 ?> G;.185 2, :>OB> =5 <>65 40 A5 >B=5A5 :J< =0@CH5=8O, 872J@H5=8 >B N@848G5A:8 ;8F0 8 54=>;8G=8 BJ@3>2F8. > 87;>65=8B5 AJ>1@065=8O ! 5 >B<5=8; $. "0:0 ?>AB0=>25=>B> @5H5=85 5 ?@028;=>. ! 5 CAB0=>28; 2O@=> D0:B8B5 ?> A;CG0O, :0B> ?@8 ?@028;=> BJ;:C20=5 =0 <0B5@80;=8O 70:>=, =0 ?@02>B> =0 ! 8 ?@8 AJ>1@07O20=5 A ?@0:B8:0B0 =0 !J40 =0 ! ?> =53>2>B> ?@8;030=5, 5 AB83=0; 4> ?@028;5= 872>4 70 =570:>=>AJ>1@07=>AB =0 $. A;CG0O A ?@>F5A=8O $ &bdquo; # .!“ 5 A0=:F8>=8@0=> 2 :0G5AB2>B> =0 A>1AB25=8: =0 ! ?> G;.101, 0;.3 , 70 B>20, G5 =0 23.03.20213., 2 11:33 G0A0, ?> ?JB -2 :<. 399+703, A ?>A>:0 =0<0;O20I :8;><5BJ@, 2:;NG5= 2 >1E20B0 =0 ?;0B5=0B0 ?JB=0 <@560, A CAB@>9AB2> ! 10072, ?@54AB02;O20I> 5;5<5=B >B 5;5:B@>==0B0 A8AB5<0 70 AJ18@0=5 =0 ?JB=8 B0:A8 ?> G;.10, 0;.1 , 5 70A5G5=> 42865=85 =0 A>1AB25=>B> <C ! – 845=B8D8F8@0=> =04;56=> ?> <0@:0, <>45;, @53.=><5@ 8 B5E=8G5A:8 E0@0:B5@8AB8:8, 70 :>5B> 87FO;> =5 5 70?;0B5=0 4J;68<0B0 ?JB=0 B0:A0 ?> G;.10, 0;.1, B.2 , B.:. =O<0 20;84=0 <0@H@CB=0 :0@B0 8;8 20;84=0 B>; 45:;0@0F8O 70 ?@5<8=020=5B> – =0@CH5=85 ?> G;.102, 0;.2 2, =0:07C5<> ?> G;.1870, 0;.2, B.3, 2@. 0;.3, 2@.G;.179, 0;.31 2. "0:0 >?8A0=>B> 2 $ 45O=85 5 AJAB02><5@=> >B >15:B82=0 8 AC15:B82=0 AB@0=0, B.:. 157A?>@=> ?@8B56020=>B> >B &bdquo; # .!“ ! 5 B0:>20 ?> G;.101, 0;.3 , 70 :>5B>, ?@8 42865=85 ?> ?;0B5=0B0 ?JB=0 <@560, A5 4J;68 B0:A0 70 87<8=0B> @07AB>O=85 - B>; B0:A0 ?> G;.10, 0;.1, B.2 . @8 ;8?A0B0 =0 40==8 70 ?>;720B5; 70 ?@52>7=>B> A@54AB2>, B0:A0B0 A5 4J;68 >B A>1AB25=8:0, ?>@048 :>5B> ?@028;=> 4@C65AB2>B> 5 845=B8D8F8@0=> :0B> AC15:B =0 =0@CH5=85B>. >:>;:>B> @07<5@JB =0 B>; B0:A8B5 A5 >?@545;O 2J7 >A=>20 =0 459AB28B5;=> 87<8=0B> @07AB>O=85, CAB0=>25=> ?>A@54AB2>< 40==8B5 >B B>; 45:;0@0F88B5 8 ?@5420@8B5;=> 70:C?5=8B5 <0@H@CB=8 :0@B8, ;8?A0B0 8 =0 425B5 157A?>@=> >1>A=>2020 872>4, G5 70 ?@>F5A=>B> !, 4J;68<0B0 ?JB=0 B0:A0 ?> G;.10, 0;.1, B.2 >B =5 5 18;0 70?;0B5=0. @028;=> ! 5 ?@85;, G5 70 ?@>F5A=>B> =0@CH5=85 =5 5 4>?CAB8<> A0=:F8>=8@0=5B> 40 A5 872J@H8 ?>A@54AB2>< AJAB02O=5B> =0 5;5:B@>=5= D8H. A;CG0O &bdquo; # .!“ 5 A0=:F8>=8@0=> 70 =0@CH5=85 =0 G;.102, 0;.2 2, =0:07C5<> ?> G;.179, 0;.31 2. %8?>B570B0 =0 =0@CH5=85 ?> G;.179, 0;.31 2 =5 5 ?>A>G5=0 2 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.1896, 0;.1 2 - 2 459AB20I0B0 :J< 21.03.20213. @540:F8O, :>OB> 87@8G=> ?@5428640 874020=5B> =0 5;5:B@>=5= D8H A0<> 70 =0@CH5=8OB0 ?> G;.179, 0;.3 2, :>8B> A0 CAB0=>25=8 8 70A=5B8 >B 5;5:B@>==0B0 A8AB5<0 ?> G;.1670, 0;.3. 57028A8<> G5 2 @07?>@5418B5 =0 G;.1670, 0;.4 8 G;.1896, 0;.7 2 A0 2:;NG5=8 8 =0@CH5=8OB0 ?> G;.179, 0;.31, ?@028;=> ! 5 ?@85;, G5 @07H8@8B5;=> BJ;:C20=5 ?@8 ?@8;030=5 =0 A0=:F8>==8 @07?>@5418 5 =54>?CAB8<>, ?>@048 :>5B> =0@CH5=85B> ?> G;.179, 0;.31 5 A;5420;> 40 A5 CAB0=>28 8 A0=:F8>=8@0 ?> >1I8O @54. ">20 BJ;:C20=5 A5 ?>B2J@64020 >B ?>A;5420;>B> 87<5=5=85 =0 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.1896, 0;.1 2 - >?. - , 1@.13 >B 20243., 2 A8;0 >B 13.02.20243., ?@8 :>5B> A0 2:;NG5=8 8 =0@CH5=8OB0 ?> G;.179, 0;.31 2. @028;=> ! 5 ?@85; 8 G5 A0=:F8>==0B0 @07?>@5410 =0 G;.179, 0;.31 2 =5 AJ>B25BAB20 =0 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.90 >B 8@5:B820 1999/62/ =0 2@>?59A:8O ?0@;0<5=B 8 =0 !J25B0 >B 17 N=8 1999 3>48=0 >B=>A=> 70?;0I0=5B> =0 B0:A8 >B B56:>B>20@=8 02B><>18;8 70 87?>;720=5 =0 >?@545;5=8 8=D@0AB@C:BC@8, 8 AJI0B0 A;5420 40 A5 >AB028 157 ?@8;>65=85. 8@5:B820 1999/62/ 5 B@0=A?>=8@0=0 A 0@5410B0 70 CA;>28OB0, @540 8 ?@028;0B0 70 873@0640=5 8 DC=:F8>=8@0=5 =0 A<5A5=0 A8AB5<0 70 B0:AC20=5 =0 @07;8G=8B5 :0B53>@88 ?JB=8 ?@52>7=8 A@54AB20 =0 1070 2@5<5 8 =0 1070 87<8=0B> @07AB>O=85 - § 2 >B , ?@85B0 =0 >A=>20=85 G;.10, 0;.7 . 0@5410B0 2J25640 878A:20=8OB0 =0 48@5:B820B0 >B=>A=> CA;>28OB0, @54JB 8 ?@028;0B0 70 873@0640=5 8 DC=:F8>=8@0=5 =0 A<5A5=0 A8AB5<0 70 B0:AC20=5 =0 @07;8G=8B5 :0B53>@88 ?JB=8 ?@52>7=8 A@54AB20 =0 1070 2@5<5 8 =0 1070 87<8=0B> @07AB>O=85. !JAB028B5 =0 04<8=8AB@0B82=8 =0@CH5=8O, A2J@70=8 AJA 70?;0I0=5B> =0 4J;68<8B5 B>; B0:A8 70 87<8=0B> @07AB>O=85, 8 ?@542845=8B5 70 BOE A0=:F88, A0 @53;0<5=B8@0=8 2 0:>=0 70 42865=85 ?> ?JB8I0B0, ?>@048 :>5B> AJI8B5 A;5420 40 A5 BJ;:C20B 2 AJ>B25BAB285 A 878A:20=8OB0 8 F5;B0 =0 8@5:B820 1999/62/. 59AB28B5;=>, :0:B> A5 A>G8 2 :0A0F8>==0B0 60;10, :J< <><5=B0 =0 ?@>25640=5 =0 ?@>872>4AB2>B> ?> 2J7782=> >160;20=5 8 ?@>87=0AO=5B> =0 ! A >160;20=>B> @5H5=85, ?@54 !! 5 18;> >1@07C20=> 45;> !-61/23, ?> ?@5N48F80;=> 70?8B20=5 =0 4<8=8AB@0B825= AJ4 - %0A:>2>, => :0B> =5 5 A?@O; ?@>872>4AB2>B> ! =5 5 4>?CA=0; AJI5AB25=> ?@>F5AC0;=> =0@CH5=85. @>B82=> =0 87;>65=>B> 2 :0A0F8>==0B0 60;10, BJ;:C20=5B> =0 ?@02>B> =0 ! =5 5 01A>;NB=0 :><?5B5=B=>AB =0 !J40 =0 !. 0?@>B82, 2A5:8 =0F8>=0;5= AJ48O >B 4J@6020 G;5=:0 5 4;J65= 40 BJ;:C20 8 ?@8;030 ?@02>B> =0 !, 2 AJ>B25BAB285 A >A=>2=8B5 ?@8=F8?8 =0 ! 8 =0 ?@0:B8:0B0 =0 !J40 =0 !. @>872>4AB20B0 ?> ?@5N48F80;=8 70?8B20=8O A0 A0<> 87@07 =0 ?@8=F8?0 =0 AJB@C4=8G5AB2> ?> G;.267 $!. 57A?>@=> BJ;:C20=5B> =0 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.90 >B 8@5:B820B0 5 >B 7=0G5=85 70 ?@028;=>B> ?@8;>65=85 =0 70:>=0, => ! 5 AJ>1@078; ?@>87=0AO=5B> =0 !! ?> ?>4>1=8 :07CA8 - 5H5=85 >B 22 <0@B 20173. ?> AJ548=5=8 45;0 Euro-Team 8 Spiral-Gep, !-497/15 8 498/15, EU:C:2017:229, 8 4045=8B5 2 B0:0 ?>AB0=>25=8B5 @5H5=8O =0A>:8 =0 =0F8>=0;=8B5 N@8A48:F88, :>8B> A0 4>AB0BJG=> :>=:@5B=8 8 OA=8 70 40 1J40B ?@8;>65=8 8 2 =0AB>OI8O A;CG09. !?>@54 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.90 >B 8@5:B820 1999/62/, 4J@6028B5 G;5=:8 CAB0=>2O20B AJ>B25B5= :>=B@>; 8 >?@545;OB A8AB5<0 >B =0:070=8O, ?@8;>68<8 70 =0@CH020=5 =0 =0F8>=0;=8B5 @07?>@5418, ?@85B8 ?> =0AB>OI0B0 48@5:B820. "5 ?@54?@85<0B 2A8G:8 =5>1E>48<8 <5@:8, 70 40 30@0=B8@0B 87?J;=5=85B> =0 B578 =0F8>=0;=8 @07?>@5418. #AB0=>25=8B5 =0:070=8O B@O120 40 1J40B 5D5:B82=8, AJ@07<5@=8 8 2J7?8@0I8. 8@5:B820 1999/62/ =5 AJ4J@60 ?@028;0 70 >?@545;O=5 =0 A0=:F88B5 =0 =0F8>=0;=> @02=8I5 8 ?>-A?5F80;=> =5 ?@5428640 87@8G=> :@8B5@88 70 ?@5F5=:0 =0 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>ABB0 =0 ?>4>1=8 A0=:F88. 0:B> 5 ?>A>G5=> 2 B.39 >B @5H5=85B> ?> >1548=5=8 45;0 Euro-Team 8 Spiral-Gep, A?>@54 ?>AB>O==0B0 AJ451=0 ?@0:B8:0 ?@8 ;8?A0 =0 E0@<>=870F8O =0 70:>=>40B5;AB2>B> =0 !JN70 2 >1;0ABB0 =0 A0=:F88B5, ?@8;>68<8 ?@8 =5A?0720=5 =0 CA;>28OB0, ?@542845=8 >B CAB0=>25= 2 B>20 70:>=>40B5;AB2> @568<, 4J@6028B5 G;5=:8 A0 :><?5B5=B=8 40 8715@0B A0=:F88, :>8B> A?>@54 BOE A0 ?>4E>4OI8. "5 2J?@5:8 B>20 A0 704J;65=8 40 C?@06=O20B :><?5B5=B=>ABB0 A8 ?@8 A?0720=5 =0 ?@02>B> =0 !JN70 8 =0 =53>28B5 >1I8 ?@8=F8?8, 0 A;54>20B5;=> 8 ?@8 A?0720=5 =0 ?@8=F8?0 =0 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>AB (B0:0 8 2 @5H5=8O >B 9 D52@C0@8 20123., Urb0n, C-210/10,EU:C:2012:64, B.23 8 >B 19 >:B><2@8 20163., EL-EM-2001, C-501/14, EU:C:2016:777, B.37). !?>@54 B.49 >B AJI>B> @5H5=85, A0=:F8>==8B5 <5@:8, ?@542845=8 2 =0F8>=0;=>B> 70:>=>40B5;AB2>, =5 B@O120 40 =04E2J@;OB 3@0=8F8B5 =0 ?>4E>4OI>B> 8 =5>1E>48<>B> 70 ?>AB830=5B> =0 ;538B8<=> ?@5A;5420=8B5 >B B>20 70:>=>40B5;AB2> F5;8, :0B> A5 8<0 ?@54284, G5 :>30B> 8<0 871>@ <564C =O:>;:> ?>4E>4OI8 <5@:8, B@O120 40 A5 ?@8153=5 4> =09-<0;:> >3@0=8G8B5;=0B0 8 G5 ?@8G8=5=8B5 =5C4>1AB20 =5 B@O120 40 A0 =5AJ@07<5@=8 ?> >B=>H5=85 =0 ?@5A;5420=8B5 F5;8 (@5H5=85 >B 19 >:B><2@8 2016, EL-EM-2001, C-501/14, EU:C:2016:777, B.39). 0:B> A;5420 >B AJ>1@065=85 1 :J< 8@5:B820 1999/62, ?@5A;5420=8B5 F5;8 2 :>=B5:AB0 =0 8@5:B820B0, A5 >B=0AOB :0:B> 4> E0@<>=870F8OB0 =0 A8AB5<8B5 =0 AJ18@0=5 =0 B0:A8, B0:0 8 4> AJ74020=5 =0 A?@0254;828 <5E0=87<8 70 2J7;030=5 =0 A515AB>9=>ABB0 =0 8=D@0AB@C:BC@0B0 =0 ?@52>720G8B5 A >3;54 >BAB@0=O20=5 =0 =0@CH5=8OB0 =0 :>=:C@5=F8OB0 <564C B@0=A?>@B=8B5 ?@54?@8OB8O =0 4J@6028B5 G;5=:8. B>78 :>=B5:AB !! 2 B.42 >B @5H5=85B> ?> >1548=5=8 45;0 Euro-Team 8 Spiral-Gep 5 ?@85;, G5 AB@>3>ABB0 =0 A0=:F88B5 B@O120 40 1J45 2 AJ>B25BAB285 A B565ABB0 =0 =0:0720=8B5 A BOE =0@CH5=8O, 2:;NG8B5;=> 8 :0B> 30@0=B8@0B @50;=> 2J7?8@0I 5D5:B, :0B> AJI52@5<5==> AJ1;N4020B >A=>2=8O ?@8=F8? =0 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>AB (@5H5=85 >B 19 >:B><2@8 20163., EL-EM-2001, C-501/14, EU:C:2016:777, B.40). B 4@C30 AB@0=0 !! 5 ?@85; 8 G5 ?@8=F8?JB =0 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>AB 5 704J;68B5;5= 70 4J@6028B5 G;5=:8, I> A5 >B=0AO =5 A0<> 4> >?@545;O=5B> =0 AJAB020 =0 =0@CH5=85B> 8 4> >?@545;O=5B> =0 ?@028;0B0 >B=>A=> B565ABB0 =0 3;>18B5, => 8 4> ?@5F5=:0B0 =0 5;5<5=B8B5, :>8B> <>30B 40 1J40B >BG8B0=8 ?@8 >?@545;O=5B> =0 3;>10B0 (@5H5=85 >B 19 >:B><2@8 20163., EL-EM-2001, C-501/14, EU:C:2016:777, B.41 8 @5H5=85B> ?> >1548=5=8 45;0 Euro-Team 8 Spiral-Gep, B.43). @8 B0:0 4045=>B> BJ;:C20=5 ?@028;=> ! 5 ?@85;, G5 B578 CA;>28O 2 A;CG0O =5 A0 87?J;=5=8 ?@8 ?@85<0=5 =0 =0F8>=0;=8B5 A0=:F8>==8 @07?>@5418, 8 ?> :>=:@5B=> =0 G;.179, 0;.31 2 8 1870, 0;.2, B.1, 2 8 3 2, B.:. ?@5428640B 3;>18 8 8<CI5AB25=8 A0=:F88 2 01A>;NB5= @07<5@ - 70 ?@>F5A=>B> =0@CH5=85 2500;2., :0B> =5 4020B =8:0:20 2J7<>6=>AB ?@8 =0;030=5B> 8< 40 A5 >BG8B0B A<5:G020I8 8;8 >B53G020I8 >B3>2>@=>ABB0 >1AB>OB5;AB20, :0:B> 8 40 1J40B ?@5F5=O20=8 5;5<5=B8 :0B> =0?@8<5@ - 87<8=0B>B> @07AB>O=85 2 =0@CH5=85 =0 878A:20=5B> 70 70?;0I0=5 =0 B>; B0:A8, @07<5@JB =0 =5?;0B5=0B0 B0:A0, ?@8G8=8B5, ?>@048 :>5B> B0:A0B0 =5 5 70?;0B5=0, ?>@54=>AB =0 =0@CH5=85B> 8 B.=. I5 A 5H5=85 >B 9 D52@C0@8 20123., Urban, !-210/10, U:C:2012:64, B>G:0 41 !! 5 ?>AB0=>28;, G5 =0;030=5B> =0 3;>10 A D8:A8@0= @07<5@ 70 2AO:> =0@CH5=85 =0 ?@028;0B0 >B=>A=> >?@545;5=8 ?@542845=8 2 70:>=0 704J;65=8O, 157 40 A5 ?@5428640 @07;8G5= @07<5@ =0 3;>10B0 2 7028A8<>AB >B B565ABB0 =0 872J@H5=>B> =0@CH5=85, 873;5640 =5?@>?>@F8>=0;=> A >3;54 =0 F5;8B5, ?>A>G5=8 2 ?@02=0B0 C@5410 =0 !JN70. "0:0, A @5H5=85B> ?> >1548=5=8 45;0 Euro-Team 8 Spiral-Gep, B>G:0 50 !! 5 ?@85;, G5 G;5= 90 >B 8@5:B820 1999/62 B@O120 40 A5 BJ;:C20 2 A<8AJ;, G5 ?@542845=>B> 2 B>78 G;5= 878A:20=5 70 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>AB =5 4>?CA:0 A8AB5<0 >B =0:070=8O 2 =0F8>=0;=0 ?@02=0 C@5410, :>OB> ?@5428640 =0;030=5B> =0 D8:A8@0=0 3;>10 70 2A8G:8 =0@CH5=8O =0 ?@028;0B0 >B=>A=> 704J;65=85B> 70 ?@5420@8B5;=> 70?;0I0=5 =0 B0:A0B0 70 ?>;720=5 =0 ?JB=0B0 8=D@0AB@C:BC@0, =57028A8<> >B E0@0:B5@0 8 B565ABB0 8<. "0:0 4045=>B> BJ;:C20=5 5 ?>B2J@45=> 8 A 5H5=85 =0 !! >B 4 >:B><2@8 20183. ?> 45;> Dooel Uvoz, !-384/17, EU:C:2018:810, :0B> AJA AJI>B>, :0:B> A;5420 >B B.38, !! 5 40; BJ;:C20=5 8 =0 ?>A;548F8B5 >B @5H5=85 >B 22 <0@B 20173., Euro-Team 8 Spiral-Gep, !-497/15 8 !-498/15. J< =0AB>OI8OB <><5=B 5 =0;8F5 ?@>87=0AO=5 8 ?> 45;> !-61/23, :0B> A 5H5=85 >B 21 =>5<2@8 20243. !! A5 5 ?>7>20; =0 25G5 4045=>B> BJ;:C20=5 A F8B8@0=>B> ?>-3>@5 @5H5=85 8 2 B.45 >B @5H5=85B> A8 5 ?@85;, G5 AB@>3>ABB0 =0 A0=:F88B5 B@O120 40 1J45 2 AJ>B25BAB285 A B565ABB0 =0 =0:0720=8B5 A BOE =0@CH5=8O, 2:;NG8B5;=> 8 :0B> 30@0=B8@0B @50;=> 2J7?8@0I 5D5:B, :0B> AJI52@5<5==> AJ1;N4020B >1I8O ?@8=F8? =0 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>AB. B.46 >B @5H5=85B> 5 ?>B2J@45=>B> 25G5 70ABJ?5=>B> AB0=>28I5 ?> AJ548=5=8 45;0 Euro-Team 8 Spiral-Gep, G5 ?@8=F8?JB =0 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>AB 5 704J;68B5;5= 70 4J@6028B5 G;5=:8, I> A5 >B=0AO =5 A0<> 4> >?@545;O=5 =0 AJAB020 =0 =0@CH5=85B> 8 4> >?@545;O=5B> =0 ?@028;0B0 >B=>A=> B565ABB0 =0 3;>18B5, => 8 4> ?@5F5=:0B0 =0 5;5<5=B8B5, :>8B> <>30B 40 1J40B >BG8B0=8 ?@8 >?@545;O=5B> =0 @07<5@0 =0 3;>10B0. B>G:8 49 8 50 >B 5H5=85B> ?> 45;> !-61/23 !J4JB =0 ! 5 ?@85;, G5 ?@>F5A=0B0 A8AB5<0 (@073;5640=0 2 3;02=>B> ?@>872>4AB2>) >B =0:070=8O =5 ?>72>;O20 40 A5 275<5 ?@54284 AB5?5=B0 =0 C<8AJ; 8;8 =5?@54?07;82>AB =0 872J@H5=>B> =0@CH5=85, 8 :0:B> A;5420 >B G;5= 1897 >B 2, 87:;NG20 ?>-:>=:@5B=> ?@8;030=5B> =0 A<5:G020I8B5 >1AB>OB5;AB20, :>8B> ?> ?@8=F8? A0 ?@542845=8 2 . !;54>20B5;=> 548=AB25=>B> ?@542845=> 2 B078 A8AB5<0 040?B8@0=5 =0 @07<5@0 3;>18B5 A5 >B=0AO 4> :0B53>@8OB0, :J< :>OB> A?040 AJ>B25B=>B> ?@52>7=> A@54AB2>, :>OB> A5 >?@545;O 2J7 >A=>20 =0 1@>O =0 >A8B5 <C. ">20 040?B8@0=5 >10G5, :>5B> 5 ;8H5=> >B :0:20B> 8 40 18;> 2@J7:0 A ?>2545=85B> =0 ?>;720B5;O =0 ?@52>7=>B> A@54AB2> 8;8 2>40G0 <C, =5 >BG8B0 E0@0:B5@0 8 B565ABB0 =0 872J@H5=>B> =0@CH5=85. "0:0 ?>-A?5F80;=> ?@8 =0;030=5B> =0 =0:070=85B> A578@0=8OB AJ4 =5 <>65 40 275<5 ?@54284 @07AB>O=85B>, 87<8=0B> >B ?@52>7=>B> A@54AB2>, 157 2>40GJB 40 5 70?;0B8; 4J;68<0B0 ?JB=0 B0:A0, BJ9 :0B> @07<5@JB =0 3;>10B0, A :>OB> A5 A0=:F8>=8@0 =587?J;=5=85B> =0 704J;65=85B> 70 ?;0I0=5, 5 D8:A8@0= 8 =5 A5 ?@><5=O =8B> 2 7028A8<>AB >B 87<8=0B8B5 157 @07@5H5=85 :8;><5B@8, =8B> A?>@54 B>20 40;8 =0@CH8B5;OB 5 70?;0B8; ?@5420@8B5;=> @07<5@0 =0 " B0:A0B0 70 4045= <0@H@CB. A25= B>20 040?B8@0=5B> 5 87:;NG5=>, 4>@8 0:> @07AB>O=85B> <>65 40 1J45 87G8A;5=> 2?>A;54AB285. B.51 >B @5H5=85B> !! 5 ?@8?><=8;, G5 AJ3;0A=> 878A:20=8OB0 =0 8@5:B820 1999/62, AJ4J@60I8 A5 ?>-A?5F80;=> 2 G;5=>25 7-7:, @073;5640=0B0 2 3;02=>B> ?@>872>4AB2> A8AB5<0 =0 " B0:A0 5 873@045=0 ?> B0:J2 =0G8=, G5 CG0AB85B> =0 ?>;720B5;8B5 2 ?>44@J6:0B0 =0 8=D@0AB@C:BC@0B0 40 5 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=> =0 87?>;720=5B> 9 8 40 >BG8B0 :0B53>@8OB0 =0 5<8A88B5, :J< :>OB> A?040 87?>;720=>B> ?@52>7=> A@54AB2>. 8?A0B0 =0 2J7<>6=>AB 70 040?B8@0=5 =0 3;>18B5 8;8 =0 8<CI5AB25=8B5 A0=:F88 2 7028A8<>AB >B B565ABB0 =0 872J@H5=>B> =0@CH5=85 >10G5 <>65 40 5 2 @07@57 A B>78 ?@8=F8? =0 CG0AB85. "0:0, 2 B.53 >B @5H5=85B> 8 ?>7>20209:8 A5 =0 BJ;:C20=5B>, 4045=> A 5H5=85 >B 22 <0@B 20173., Euro-Team 8 Spir0l-G5p, C-497/15 8 C-498/15, EU:C:2017:229, B.49, !! 5 ?@85;, G5 ?@8 B578 CA;>28O =0;030=5B> =0 3;>10 8;8 =0 8<CI5AB25=0 A0=:F8O A D8:A8@0= @07<5@ 70 2AO:> =0@CH5=85 =0 =O:>8 ?@542845=8 2 70:>=0 704J;65=8O, 157 40 A5 ?@5428640 @07;8G5= @07<5@ =0 B078 3;>10 8;8 8<CI5AB25=0 A0=:F8O 2 7028A8<>AB >B B565ABB0 =0 =0@CH5=85B>, :0:B> ?@5428640 @073;5640=0B0 2 3;02=>B> ?@>872>4AB2> A8AB5<0 >B =0:070=8O, 873;5640 =5?@>?>@F8>=0;=> A >3;54 =0 F5;8B5, ?>A>G5=8 2 ?@02=0B0 C@5410 =0 !JN70. 70:;NG5=85 !! 5 ?@85;, G5: &bdquo;';5= 90 >B 8@5:B820 1999/62/ =0 2@>?59A:8O ?0@;0<5=B 8 =0 !J25B0 >B 17 N=8 1999 3>48=0 >B=>A=> 70?;0I0=5B> =0 B0:A8 >B B56:>B>20@=8 02B><>18;8 70 87?>;720=5 =0 >?@545;5=8 8=D@0AB@C:BC@8, 87<5=5=0 A 8@5:B820 2011/76/! =0 2@>?59A:8O ?0@;0<5=B 8 =0 !J25B0 >B 27 A5?B5<2@8 20113., B@O120 40 A5 BJ;:C20 2 A<8AJ;, G5 ?>A>G5=>B> 2 =53> 878A:20=5 70 AJ@07<5@=>AB =5 4>?CA:0 A8AB5<0 >B =0:070=8O, :>OB> ?@5428640 =0;030=5 =0 3;>10 8;8 8<CI5AB25=0 A0=:F8O A D8:A8@0= @07<5@ 70 2A8G:8 =0@CH5=8O =0 ?@028;0B0 >B=>A=> 704J;65=85B> 70 ?@5420@8B5;=> 70?;0I0=5 =0 B0:A0B0 70 ?>;720=5 =0 ?JB=0B0 8=D@0AB@C:BC@0, =57028A8<> >B E0@0:B5@0 8 B565ABB0 8<, 2:;NG8B5;=> :>30B> B078 A8AB5<0 ?@5428640 2J7<>6=>ABB0 70 >A2>1>64020=5 >B 04<8=8AB@0B82=>=0:070B5;=0 >B3>2>@=>AB G@57 70?;0I0=5 =0 &bdquo;:><?5=A0B>@=0 B0:A0“ A D8:A8@0= @07<5@“. @8 B0:0 ?>B2J@45=>B> BJ;:C20=5 =0 @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.90 >B 8@5:B820 1999/62/ 8 =0 ?@54E>4=8B5 @5H5=8O =0 !! - =0 :>8B> A5 5 ?>7>20; !, 2J7782=8OB AJ4 =5 5 4>?CA=0; ?@>F5AC0;=> =0@CH5=85, =0?@>B82 - BJ;:C20; 5 ?@02>B> =0 ! 2 AJ>B25BAB285 A ?@0:B8:0B0 =0 !J40 =0 !. :>=B5:AB0 =0 ?>AB0=>25=>B> @5H5=85 ?> 45;> !-61/23, ?@028;=> ! 5 ?@85; 8 G5 >B3>2>@8B5 ?> =53> A0<> G0AB8G=> I5 4>?@8=5A0B 70 ?@028;=>B> @5H020=5 =0 =0AB>OI8O A?>@, B.:. 2 :>=B5:AB0, 2 :>9B> 5 D>@<C;8@0= 2J?@>A0 >B ?@5N48F80;=>B> 70?8B20=5, A5 8A:0 BJ;:C20=5 A0<> =0 878A:20=8OB0 70 AJ@07<5@=>AB 8 ?@>?>@F8>=0;=>AB, 2J2545=8 A G;.90 >B 8@5:B820B0, => =5 8 :0:2> A;5420 :0B> ?>A;548F0 >B 525=BC0;=>B> :>=AB0B8@0=5 =0 =5AJ>B25BAB285 =0 =0F8>=0;=>B> 70:>=>40B5;AB2>. ">78 2J?@>A >10G5 5 87A;5420= >B !! 2 ?>AB0=>25=>B> >B =53> 5H5=85 >B 4 >:B><2@8 20183. ?> 45;> Dooel Uvoz, !-384/20173. B.53 >B AJI>B> 5 ?@85B>, G5 B.:. @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.90 >B 8@5:B820 1999/62 878A:20 =0<5A0B0 =0 4J@6028B5 G;5=:8 8 8< ?@54>AB02O 7=0G8B5;=0 A2>1>40 =0 ?@5F5=:0, AJI0B0 =O<0 48@5:B5= 5D5:B. 1@0B=>B> BJ;:C20=5 =0 ?@0:B8:0 18 4>25;> 4> ?@5<0E20=5 =0 ?@02>B> =0 ?@5F5=:0, ?@54>AB025=> 548=AB25=> =0 =0F8>=0;=8B5 70:>=>40B5;8, :>8B> A;5420 40 @07@01>BOB ?>4E>4OI A0=:F8>=5= @568< 2 @0<:8B5, >?@545;5=8 >B G;.90 >B 8@5:B820B0 - B.54 >B @5H5=85B>. !?>@54 B.55 8 B.57 >B @5H5=85B>, >B B>20 A;5420, G5 878A:20=5B> 70 AJ@07<5@=>AB =0 =0:070=8OB0, ?@542845=> 2 G;.90 >B 8@5:B820 1999/62/, =5 <>65 40 A5 BJ;:C20 2 A<8AJ;, G5 704J;6020 =0F8>=0;=8O AJ4 40 70<5AB8 =0F8>=0;=8O 70:>=>40B5;. J?@5:8 B>20 AJ3;0A=> ?>AB>O==0B0 AJ451=0 ?@0:B8:0 ?@>87B8G0I>B> >B 4045=0 48@5:B820 704J;65=85 70 4J@6028B5 G;5=:8 40 ?>AB83=0B ?@542845=8O 2 =5O @57C;B0B, :0:B> 8 704J;65=85B> 8< ?> G;5= 4, ?0@03@0D 3 ! 8 =0 G;5= 288 $! 40 ?@54?@85<0B 2A8G:8 =5>1E>48<8 <5@:8, >1I8 8;8 A?5F80;=8, 70 40 >A83C@OB 87?J;=5=85B> =0 B>20 704J;65=85, B568 2J@EC 2A8G:8 >@30=8 =0 4J@6028B5 G;5=:8, 2:;NG8B5;=> — 2 @0<:8B5 =0 BOE=0B0 :><?5B5=B=>AB — 2J@EC AJ451=8B5 >@30=8 (B0:0 8 2 @5H5=8O >B 14 A5?B5<2@8 20163., Martinez Andres 8 Castrejana Lopez, C-184/15 8 C-197/15, EU:C:2016:680, B.50 8 F8B8@0=0B0 AJ451=0 ?@0:B8:0, 8 >B 24 O=C0@8 20183., Pantuso 8 4@., C-616/16 8 C-617/16, EU:C:2018:32, B.42). !?>@54 B.58 8 B.59 >B @5H5=85B> ?> 45;>B> Dooel Uvoz, 70 40 87?J;=8 B>20 704J;65=85, ?@8=F8?JB 70 AJ>B25BAB20I> BJ;:C20=5 878A:20 =0F8>=0;=8B5 N@8A48:F88 40 87?>;720B 2A8G:8 A2>8 ?@02><>I8O, :0B> 275<0B ?@54284 2JB@5H=>B> ?@02> 2 =53>20B0 FO;>AB 8 :0B> ?@8;>60B ?@87=0B8B5 >B ?>A;54=>B> <5B>48 70 BJ;:C20=5, 70 40 30@0=B8@0B ?J;=0B0 5D5:B82=>AB =0 ?@02>B> =0 !JN70 8 40 AB83=0B 4> @07@5H5=85, :>5B> AJ>B25BAB20 =0 ?@5A;5420=0B0 >B =53> F5; (@5H5=8O >B 13 N;8 20163., P>pperl, C-187/15, EU:C:2016:550, B.43 8 >B 28 N=8 20183., Crespo Rey, C-2/17, EU:C:2018:511, B.70). "0:0, 704J;65=85B> =0 =0F8>=0;=8O AJ4 40 A5 ?>7>25 =0 AJ4J@60=85B> =0 ?@02>B> =0 !JN70, :>30B> BJ;:C20 8 ?@8;030 @5;520=B=8B5 =>@<8 =0 2JB@5H=>B> ?@02>, 5 >3@0=8G5=> >B >1I8B5 ?@8=F8?8 =0 ?@02>B> 8 =5 <>65 40 A;C68 :0B> >A=>20 70 BJ;:C20=5 contra legem =0 =0F8>=0;=>B> ?@02> (@5H5=85 >B 13 N;8 20163., P>pperl, C-187/15, EU:C:2016:550, B.44). B>G:0 61 >B @5H5=85B> ?> 45;>B> Dooel Uvoz 5 ?@85B>, G5 2J?@5:8 B>20, >B ?>AB>O==0B0 AJ451=0 ?@0:B8:0 A;5420 AJI>, G5 0:> =5 5 2J7<>6=> B0:>20 AJ>B25BAB20I> BJ;:C20=5, =0F8>=0;=0B0 N@8A48:F8O 5 4;J6=0 40 ?@8;>68 ?@02>B> =0 !JN70 2 =53>20B0 FO;>AB 8 40 70I8B8 ?@020B0, :>8B> B> 4020 =0 G0AB=>?@02=8B5 AC15:B8, :0B> ?@8 =5>1E>48<>AB >AB028 157 ?@8;>65=85 2AO:0 @07?>@5410, :>OB>, 0:> 1J45 ?@8;>65=0, ?@54284 >1AB>OB5;AB20B0 ?> A;CG0O, 18 4>25;0 4> =5AJ>B25BAB20I =0 ?@02>B> =0 !JN70 @57C;B0B (@5H5=85 >B 13 N;8 20163., P>pperl, C-187/15, EU:C:2016:550, B.45). @028;=> ! 5 ?@85;, G5 8<5==> B078 E8?>B570 5 =0;8F5 2 A;CG0O. "J9 :0B> @07?>@5418B5 =0 G;.179, 0;.31 2 8 1870, 0;.2, B.1, 2 8 3 2 =5 4>?CA:0B 872J@H20=5B> =0 ?@5F5=:0 >B=>A=> B565ABB0 =0 A0=:F88B5 8 =0 5;5<5=B8B5, :>8B> <>30B 40 1J40B >BG8B0=8 ?@8 >?@545;O=5 =0 B5E=8O @07<5@, 0 ?@5428640B 3;>18 8 8<CI5AB25=8 A0=:F88 2 01A>;NB5= @07<5@, 8 4>:>;:>B> 2 ?@02><>I8OB0 8 :><?5B5=F88B5 =0 AJ40 =5 A5 2:;NG20 >?@545;O=5B> =0 ?>4E>4OI A0=:F8>=5= @568<, 0 A0<> ?@8;030=5B> =0 ?@85B8O B0:J2 >B 70:>=>40B5;=8B5 >@30=8, =5 5 2J7<>6=> BJ;:C20=5 =0 =0F8>=0;=8O 70:>= ?> =0G8=, AJ>B25B5= =0 8@5:B820B0, ?>@048 :>5B> 8 548=AB25=8OB =0G8=, :>9B> 30@0=B8@0 ?J;=0B0 5D5:B82=>AB =0 ?@02>B> =0 !JN70 8 70I8B020 ?@54>AB025=8B5 =0 G0AB=>?@02=8B5 AC15:B8 ?@020, 5 =5?@>?>@F8>=0;=0B0 =0F8>=0;=0 A0=:F8>==0 C@5410 - G;.179, 0;.31 2, 2@. G;.1870, 0;.2, B.3 2, 40 1J45 >AB025=0 157 ?@8;>65=85, B.:. 2 ?@>B825= A;CG09 18 A5 AB83=0;> 4> =5AJ>B25BAB20I =0 ?@02>B> =0 !JN70 @57C;B0B. @028;=0 5 ?@5F5=:0B0, G5 2 ?>4>1=8 A;CG08 A;5420 40 A5 872J@H8 ?@>25@:0 40;8 AJI5AB2C20 >1I0 04<8=8AB@0B82=>=0:070B5;=0 @07?>@5410, :>OB> ?@5428640 =0;030=5B> =0 8<CI5AB25=8 A0=:F88 70 =0@CH5=8O =0 2, 70 :>8B> =5 5 ?@542845=0 4@C30 A0=:F8O. A;CG0O B0:020 >1I0 A0=:F8>==0 @07?>@5410 ;8?A20. 48=AB25=0B0 >1I0 A0=:F8>==0 =>@<0 5 B078 =0 G;.185 2, => AJI0B0 5 ?@5428640 548=AB25=> =0;030=5B> =0 3;>10 8 ?> 0@3. >B @07?>@5410B0 =0 G;.83, 0;.1 - :>OB> 878A:20 A;CG08B5, 2 :>8B> =0 . 8 " A5 =0;030B A0=:F88 40 A0 87@8G=> C@545=8 2 70:>=, =5 <>65 40 A5 >B=5A5 :J< =0@CH5=8O, 872J@H5=8 >B N@848G5A:8 ;8F0 8 54=>;8G=8 BJ@3>2F8. 0B> 5 AB83=0; 4> AJI8B5 ?@02=8 872>48, ! 5 ?>AB0=>28; ?@028;=> @5H5=85, :>5B> :0B> 20;84=> 8 4>?CAB8<>, A;5420 40 1J45 >AB025=> 2 A8;0. @8 B>78 87E>4 =0 A?>@0, 2 ?>;70 =0 >B25B=0B0 AB@0=0 A;5420 40 A5 ?@8AJ4OB AB>@5=8B5 2 ?@>872>4AB2>B> @07=>A:8, 0 8<5==> 600,00;2. 70 042>:0BA:> 2J7=03@0645=85, :>5B> 284=> >B 4>3>2>@ 70 ?@02=0 70I8B0 8 AJ459AB285 ! 940/14.05.20243. 5 87?;0B5=> 87FO;> 2 1@>9. J7@065=85B> =0 :0A0B>@0 70 ?@5:><5@=>AB 5 =5>A=>20B5;=>, B.:. 4>3>2>@5=>B> 8 87?;0B5=> 042>:0BA:> 2J7=03@0645=85 :>@5A?>=48@0 87FO;> A D0:B8G5A:0B0 8 ?@02=0 A;>6=>AB =0 A?>@0, 8 A >15<0 =0 ?@54>AB025=0B0 042>:0BA:0 70I8B0, ?>@048 :>5B> ;8?A20B >A=>20=8O 70 =53>2>B> @54CF8@0=5. >48< >B 3>@=>B> 8 =0 >A=>20=85 G;.221, 0;.2 , 0@=5=A:8OB 04<8=8AB@0B825= AJ4, I-28 B@8G;5=5= AJAB02   (:   !"/ ! 5H5=85 ! 93/25.03.20243. =0 09>=5= AJ4 - 52=O, -B8 AJAB02, ?>AB0=>25=> ?> % ! 334/20233. ?> >?8A0 =0 AJI8O AJ4. !* 35=F8O &bdquo;JB=0 8=D@0AB@C:BC@0“, ****, [=0A5;5=> <OAB>] 40 70?;0B8 =0 &bdquo; # .!“ , ****, AJA A540;8I5 8 04@5A =0 C?@02;5=85 [=0A5;5=> <OAB>], [C;8F0], ?@54AB02;O20=> 7054=> >B C?@028B5;8B5 . . . 8 . . !., @07=>A:8 70 ?@>872>4AB2>B>, 2 @07<5@ =0 600 (H5ABAB>B8=) ;520. 5H5=85B> 5 >:>=G0B5;=>! </div>    <div class="BreakerSignature" dir="ltr" style="margin: 30px 0 200px 0;"> <table border="0" class="body-text" dir="ltr" style="width: 100%;"> <tbody> <tr> <td style="text-align: right; vertical-align: top;">@54A540B5;: </td> <td style="width: 205px;"> </td> </tr> <tr> <td style="text-align: right; vertical-align: top;padding-top: 20px">25">';5=>25: </td> <td style="width: 205px;padding-top: 20px"> </td> </tr> </tbody> </table> </div>

Номер на акта:	689
Дата:	20 януари 2025 г. (в сила от 20 януари 2025 г.)
Съдия:	Искрена Димитрова

Дело:	20247050701111
Тип на делото:	Касационно административно наказателно дело
Дата на образуване:	23 май 2024 г.

Решение по КНАХД №1111/2024 на Административен съд - Варна

Съдържание на акта